|
S. Bernard, B.A., A. Enayati, M.S.M.E., L. Redwood, M.S.N.,
H. Roger, B.A., T. Binstock
Sallie Bernard, ARC Research, 14 Commerce Drive, Cranford, NJ 07901 USA,
908.276.6300, fax 908.276.1301
Summary
Autism is a syndrome characterized by impairments
in social relatedness and communication, repetitive behaviors, abnormal
movements, and sensory dysfunction. Recent epidemiological studies suggest
that autism may affect 1 in 150 U. S. children.
Exposure to mercury can cause immune, sensory, neurological,
motor, and behavioral dysfunctions similar to traits defining or associated
with autism, and the similarities extend to neuroanatomy, neurotransmitters,
and biochemistry.
Thimerosal, a preservative added to many vaccines,
has become a major source of mercury in children who, within their first
two years, may have received a quantity of mercury that exceeds safety
guidelines.
A review of medical literature and U.S. government
data suggests that
i) many cases of idiopathic autism are induced by
early mercury exposure from thimerosal;
(ii) this type of autism represents an unrecognized
mercurial syndrome; and
(iii) genetic and non-genetic factors establish
a predisposition whereby thimerosal's adverse effects occur only in
some children.
Introduction
Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a neurodevelopmental
syndrome with onset prior to age 36 months. Diagnostic criteria consist
of impairments in sociality and communication plus repetitive and stereotypic
behaviors (1). Traits strongly associated with autism include movement
disorders and sensory dysfunctions (2). Although autism may be apparent
soon after birth, most autistic children experience at least several months,
even a year or more of normal development -- followed by regression, defined
as loss of function or failure to progress (2,3,4).
The neurotoxicity
of mercury (Hg) has long been recognized
(5).
Primary data derive from victims of contaminated fish
(Japan - Minamata Disease) or grain (Iraq, Guatemala, Russia); from acrodynia
(Pink Disease) induced by Hg in teething powders; and from individual
instances of mercury poisoning (HgP), many occurring in occupational settings
(e.g., Mad Hatter's Disease).
Animal and in vitro studies also provide insights
into the mechanisms of Hg toxicity. More recently, the Food and Drug Administration
(FDA) and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) have determined that
the typical amount of Hg injected into infants and toddlers via childhood
immunizations has exceeded government safety guidelines on an individual
(6) and cumulative vaccine basis (7).
The mercury in vaccines
derives from thimerosal (TMS), a preservative which is 49.6% ethylmercury
(eHg) (7).
Past cases of HgP have presented with much inter-individual
variation, depending on the dose, type of mercury, method of administration,
duration of exposure, and individual sensitivity. Thus, while commonalities
exist across the various instances of HgP, each set of variables has given
rise to a different disease manifestation (8,9,10,11).
It is hypothesized that the regressive form of
autism represents another form of mercury poisoning, based on a thorough
correspondence between autistic and HgP traits and physiological abnormalities,
as well as on the known exposure to mercury through vaccines.
Furthermore, other phenomena are consistent with a
causal Hg-ASD relationship. These include:
a) symptom onset shortly after immunization;
(b) ASD prevalence increases corresponding to vaccination
increases; (c) similar sex ratios of affected individuals;
(d) a high heritability rate for autism paralleling
a genetic predisposition to Hg sensitivity at low doses; and
(e) parental reports of autistic children with elevated
Hg.
Trait Comparison
ASD manifests a constellation of symptoms with much
inter-individual variation (3,4). A comparison of traits defining, nearly
universal to, or commonly found in autism with those known to arise from
mercury poisoning is given in Table I. The characteristics defining or
strongly associated with autism are also more fully described.
Autism has been conceived primarily as a psychiatric
condition; and two of its three diagnostic criteria are based upon the
observable traits of
a) impairments in sociality, most commonly social
withdrawal or aloofness, and
b) a variety of perseverative or stereotypic behaviors
and the need for sameness, which strongly resemble obsessive-compulsive
tendencies.
Differential diagnosis may include childhood schizophrenia,
depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), anxiety disorder, and
other neuroses.
Related behaviors commonly found in ASD individuals
are irrational fears, poor eye contact, aggressive behaviors, temper tantrums,
irritability, and inexplicable changes in mood (1,2,12-17). Mercury poisoning,
when undetected, is often initially diagnosed as a psychiatric disorder
(18).
Commonly occurring symptoms include:
a) "extreme shyness," indifference to
others, active avoidance of others, or "a desire to be alone";(b)
depression, "lack of interest" and "mental confusion;"
(c) irritability, aggression, and tantrums in children
and adults;
(d) anxiety and fearfulness; and
(e) emotional lability.
Neuroses, including schizoid and obsessive-compulsive
traits, problems in inhibition of perseveration, and stereotyped behaviors,
have been reported in a number of cases; and lack of eye contact was observed
in one 12 year old girl with mercury vapor poisoning (18-35).
The third diagnostic criterion for ASD is impairment
in communication (1). Historically, about half of those with classic autism
failed to develop meaningful speech (2), and articulation difficulties
are common (3). Higher functioning individuals may have language fluency
but still show semantic and pragmatic errors (3,36). In many cases of
ASD, verbal IQ is lower than performance IQ (3). Similarly, mercury-exposed
children and adults show a marked difficulty with speech (9,19,37).
In milder cases scores on language tests may be lower
than those of unexposed controls (31,38). Iraqi children who were postnatally
poisoned developed articulation problems, from slow, slurred word production
to an inability to generate meaningful speech; while Iraqi babies exposed
prenatally either failed to develop language or presented with severe
language deficits in childhood (23,24,39). Workers with Mad Hatter's disease
had word retrieval and articulation difficulties (21).
Nearly all cases of ASD
and HgP involve disorders of physical movement
(2,30,40).
Clumsiness or lack of coordination has been described
in many higher functioning ASD individuals (41). Infants and toddlers
later diagnosed with autism may fail to crawl properly or may fall over
while sitting or standing; and the movement disturbances typically occur
on the right side of the body (42). Problems with intentional movement
and imitation are common in ASD, as are a variety of unusual stereotypic
behaviors such as toe walking, rocking, abnormal postures, choreiform
movements, spinning; and hand flapping (2,3,43,44).
Noteworthy because of
similarities to autism are reports in Hg literature of:
a) children in Iraq and Japan who were unable to
stand, sit, or crawl (34,39);
(b) Minamata disease patients whose movement disturbances
were localized to one side of the body, and a girl exposed to Hg vapor
who tended to fall to the right (18,34);
(c) flapping motions in an infant poisoned from
contaminated pork (37) and in a man injected with thimerosal (27);
(d) choreiform movements in mercury vapor intoxication
(19);
(e) toe walking in a moderately poisoned Minamata
child (34);
(f) poor coordination and clumsiness among victims
of acrodynia (45);
(g) rocking among infants with acrodynia (11); and
(h) unusual postures observed in both acrodynia
and mercury vapor poisoning (11,31). The presence of flapping motions
in both diseases is of interest because it is such an unusual behavior
that it has been recommended as a diagnostic marker for autism (46).
Virtually all ASD subjects show a variety of sensory
abnormalities (2). Auditory deficits are present in a minority of individuals
and can range from mild to profound hearing loss (2,47). Over- or under-reaction
to sound is nearly universal (2,48), and deficits in language comprehension
are often present (3). Pain sensitivity or insensitivity is common, as
is a general aversion to touch; abnormal sensation in the extremities
and mouth may also be present and has been detected even in toddlers under
12 months old (2,49).
There may be a variety of visual disturbances, including
sensitivity to light (2,50,51,52). As in autism, sensory issues are reported
in virtually all instances of Hg toxicity (40). HgP can lead to mild to
profound hearing loss (40); speech discrimination is especially impaired
(9,34,). Iraqi babies exposed prenatally showed exaggerated reaction to
noise (23), while in acrodynia, patients reported noise sensitivity (45).
Abnormal sensation in the extremities and mouth is the most common sensory
disturbance (25,28). Acrodynia sufferers and prenatally exposed Iraqi
babies exhibited excessive pain when bumping limbs and an aversion to
touch (23,24,45,53). A range of visual problems has been reported, including
photophobia (18,23,34).
Comparison Of Biological Abnormalities
The biological abnormalities commonly found in autism
are listed in Table II, along with the corresponding pathologies arising
from mercury exposure. Especially noteworthy similarities are described.
Autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder which has
been characterized as "a disorder of neuronal organization, that
is, the development of the dentritic tree, synaptogenesis, and the development
of the complex connectivity within and between brain regions" (54).
Depressed expression of neural cell adhesion molecules (NCAMs), which
are critical during brain development for proper synaptic structuring,
has been found in one study of autism (55). Organic mercury, which readily
crosses the blood-brain barrier, preferentially targets nerve cells and
nerve fibers (56); primates accumulate the highest Hg-levels in the brain
relative to other organs (40).
Furthermore, although most cells respond to mercurial
injury by modulating levels of glutathione (GSH), metallothionein, hemoxygenase,
and other stress proteins, neurons tend to be "markedly deficient
in these responses" and thus are less able to remove Hg and more
prone to Hg-induced injury (56). In the developing brain, mercury interferes
with neuronal migration, depresses cell division, disrupts microtubule
function, and reduces NCAMs (28, 57-59).
While damage has been observed in a number of brain
areas in autism, many nuclei and functions are spared (36). HgPs
damage is similarly selective (40). Numerous studies link autism with
neuronal atypicalities within the amygdala, hippocampi, basal ganglia,
the Purkinje and granule cells of the cerebellum, brainstem, basal ganglia,
and cerebral cortex (36,60-69). Each of these areas can be affected by
HgP (10,34,40,70-73). Migration of Hg, including eHg, into the amygdala
is particularly noteworthy, because in primates this brain region has
neurons specific for eye contact (74) and it is implicated in autism and
in social behaviors (65,66,75).
Autistic brains show neurotransmitter
irregularities which are virtually identical to those arising from Hg
exposure:
- both high or low serotonin and dopamine, depending
on the subjects studied;
- elevated epinephrine and norepinephrine in plasma
and brain; elevated glutamate; and
- acetylcholine deficiency in hippocampus (2,21,76-83).
Gillberg and Coleman (2) estimate that 35-45% of autistics
eventually develop epilepsy. A recent MEG study reported epileptiform
activity in 82% of 50 regressive autistic children; in another study,
half the autistic children expressed abnormal EEG activity during sleep
(84). Autistic EEG abnormalities tend to be non-specific and have a variety
of patterns (85). Unusual epileptiform activity has been found in a number
of mercury poisoning cases (18,27,34,86-88).
Early Hg exposure enhances tendencies toward epileptiform
activity with a reduced level of seizure-discharge amplitude (89), a finding
consistent with the subtlety of seizures in many autism spectrum children
(84,85). The fact that Hg increases extracellular glutamate would also
contribute to epileptiform activity (90).
Some autistic children show a low capacity to oxidize
sulfur compounds and low levels of sulfate (91,92). These findings may
be linked with HgP because (a) Hg preferentially binds to sulfhydryl molecules
(-SH) such as cysteine and GSH, thereby impairing various cellular functions
(40), and (b) mercury can irreversibly block the sulfate transporter NaSi
cotransporter NaSi-1, present in kidneys and intestines, thus reducing
sulfate absorption (93).
Besides low sulfate, many autistics have low GSH levels,
abnormal GSH-peroxidase activity within erythrocytes, and decreased hepatic
ability to detoxify xenobiotics (91,94,95). GSH participates in cellular
detoxification of heavy metals (96); hepatic GSH is a primary substrate
for organic-Hg clearance from the human (40); and intraneuronal GSH participates
in various protective responses against Hg in the CNS (56).
By preferentially binding with GSH, preventing absorption
of sulfate, or inhibiting the enzymes of glutathione metabolism (97),
Hg might diminish GSH bioavailability. Low GSH can also derive from chronic
infection (98,99), which would be more likely in the presence of immune
impairments arising from mercury (100).
Furthermore, mercury disrupts purine and pyrimidine
metabolism (97,10). Altered purine or pyrimidine metabolism can induce
autistic features and classical autism (2,101,102), suggesting another
mechanism by which Hg can contribute to autistic traits.
Autistics are more likely
to have:
- allergies
- asthma
- selective IgA deficiency (sIgAd)
- enhanced expression of HLA-DR antigen
- and an absence of interleukin-2 receptors
- as well as familial autoimmunity
- and a variety of autoimmune phenomena
- These include elevated serum IgG
- and ANA titers,
- IgM and
- IgG brain antibodies,
- and myelin basic protein (MBP) antibodies (103-110).
Similarly, atypical responses to Hg have been ascribed
to allergic or autoimmune reactions (8), and genetic predisposition to
such reactions may explain why Hg sensitivity varies so widely by individual
(88,111).
Children who developed acrodynia were more likely
to have asthma and other allergies (11); IgG brain autoantibodies, MBP,
and ANA have been found in HgP subjects (18,111,112); and mice genetically
prone to develop autoimmune diseases "are highly susceptible to mercury-induced
immunopathological alterations" even at the lowest doses (113).
Additionally, many autistics have reduced natural
killer cell (NK) function, as well as immune-cell subsets shifted in a
Th2 direction and increased urine neopterin levels, indicating immune
system activiation (103,114-116). Depending upon genetic predisposition,
Hg can induce immune activation, an expansion of Th2 subsets, and decreased
NK activity (117-120).
Population Characteristics
In most affected children, autistic symptoms emerge
gradually, although there are cases of sudden onset (3).
The earliest abnormalities have been detected in 4
month olds and consist of subtle movement disturbances; subtle motor-sensory
disturbances have been observed in 9 month olds (49). More overt speech
and hearing difficulties become noticeable to parents and pediatricians
between 12 and 18 months (2). TMS vaccines have been given in repeated
intervals starting from infancy and continuing until 12 to 18 months.
While HgP symptoms, may arise suddenly in especially
sensitive individuals (11), usually there is a preclinical "silent
stage" in which subtle neurological changes are occuring (121) and
then a gradual emergence of symptoms.
The first symptoms are typically sensory- and motor-related,
which are followed by speech and hearing deficits, and finally the full
array of HgP characteristics (40).
Thus, both the timing
and nature of symptom emergence in ASD are fully consistent with a vaccinal
Hg etiology.
This parallel is reinforced by parental reports of
excessive amounts of mercury in urine or hair from younger autistic children,
as well as some improvement in symptoms with standard chelation therapy
(122).
The discovery and rise
in prevalence of ASD mirrors the introduction and spread of thimerosol
in vaccines.
Autism was first described in 1943 among children
born in the 1930s (123). Thimerosal was first introduced into vaccines
in the 1930s (7). In studies conducted prior to 1970, autism prevalence
was estimated, at 1 in 2000; in studies from 1970 to 1990 it averaged
1 in 1000 (124). This was a period of increased vaccination rates of the
TMS-containing DPT vaccines among children in the developed world.
In the early 1990s, the prevalence of autism was found
to be 1 in 500 (125), and in 2000 the CDC found 1 in 150 children affected
in one community, which was consistent with reports from other areas in
the country (126). In the late 1980s and early 1990s, two new TMS vaccines,
the HIB and Hepatitis B, were added to the recommended schedule (7).
Nearly
all US children are immunized, yet only a small proportion develop autism.
A pertinent characteristic of mercury is the great
variability in its effects by individual, so that at the same exposure
level, some will be affected severely while others will be asymptomatic
(9,11,28). An example is acrodynia, which arose in the early 20th Century
from mercury in teething powders and afflicted only 1 in 500-1000 children
given the same low dose (28).
Studies in mice as well as humans indicate that susceptibility
to Hg effects arises from genetic status, in some cases including a propensity
to autoimmune disorders (113,34,40). ASD exhibits a strong genetic component,
with high concordance in monozygotic twins and a higher than expected
incidence among siblings (4); autism is also more prevalent in families
with autoimmune disorders (106).
Additionally, autism is more prevalent among boys
than girls, with the ratio estimated at 4:1 (2). Mercury studies in mice
and humans consistently report greater effects on males than females,
except for kidney damage (57). At high doses, both sexes are affected
equally; at low doses only males are affected (38,40,127).
Discussion
We have shown that
every major characteristic of autism has been exhibited in at least several
cases of documented mercury poisoning.
Recently, the FDA and AAP have revealed that the
amount of mercury given to infants from vaccinations has exceeded safety
levels. The timing of mercury administration via vaccines coincides with
the onset of autistic symptoms. Parental reports of autistic children
with measurable mercury levels in hair and urine indicate a history of
mercury exposure. Thus the standard primary criteria for a diagnosis of
mercury poisoning - observable symptoms, known exposure at the time of
symptom onset, and detectable levels in biologic samples (11,31) - have
been met in autism.
As such, mercury toxicity may be a significant etiological
factor in at least some cases of regressive autism. Further, each known
form of HgP in the past has resulted in a unique variation of mercurialism
- e.g., Minamata disease, acrodynia, Mad Hatters disease - none
of which has been autism, suggesting that the Hg source which may be involved
in ASD has not yet been characterized; given that most infants receive
eHg via vaccines, and given that the effect on infants of eHg in vaccines
has never been studied (129), vaccinal thimerosal should be considered
a probable source. It is also possible that vaccinal eHg may be additive
to a prenatal mercury load derived from maternal amalgams, immune globulin
injections, or fish consumption, and environmental sources.
Conclusion
The history of acrodynia illustrates that a severe
disorder, afflicting a small but significant percentage of children, can
arise from a seemingly benign application of low doses of mercury. This
review establishes the likelihood that Hg may likewise be etiologically
significant in ASD, with the Hg derived from thimerosal in vaccines rather
than teething powders. Due to the extensive parallels between autism and
HgP, the likelihood of a causal relationship is great. Given this possibility,
TMS should be removed from all childhood vaccines, and the mechanisms
of Hg toxicity in autism should be thoroughly investigated.
With perhaps 1 in 150
children now diagnosed with ASD, development of HgP-related treatments,
such as chelation, would prove beneficial for this large and seemingly
growing population.
For
References Click Here
Originally published in the
FEAT (http://www.feat.org) online newsletter.
|