The threat of the flu vaccine seems to be poking its head out once
again, for a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) panel
is entertaining a dangerous decision: To implement a blanket recommendation
for universal immunization for all Americans -- not just young children,
the elderly and other at-risk individuals. Worse, it could be phased
in within the next five years.
And while the government has consistently expanded the list of
people who should receive the flu shot, this bold step takes the
cake.
Hurdles on the Horizon
According to observers, however, the obstacles of the decision
are daunting:
For starters, the unstable supply of the vaccine is a major concern.
A CDC spokesperson acknowledged talk of universal immunization
was put on the back burner when reports surfaced that all of the
initial supply of flu vaccines manufactured by Chiron last year
were tainted.
Also, the government panel estimates 90 million vaccines will
be available for the next flu season -- which is only half of
what they claim is needed to cover the demand for "high-risk"
patients.
And, since the flu vaccine is altered every year because there
are always different flu strains lurking about, the unused vaccine
is thrown out at the end of the season, making the shots unappealing
to manufacturers, from a financial standpoint.
Mind the Negative Note ...
While high demand has historically been a problem, many on the
opposite end of the spectrum believe the vaccine is unsafe. In fact,
one medical study suggested the
vaccine didn't even save lives among elderly people.
Thus, the burning question is: What will universal immunization
do for America's health?
BusinessWeek
May 12, 2005
|