FREE Subscription
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter   
 
 
POSTED BY
September 17 2000
1,894 Views

BROWSE BY CATEGORY

Cooked Carrots vs. Raw

 

New research suggests that cooking and mashing up carrots may increase their antioxidant value.

Researchers from the University of Arkansas in Fayetteville heated carrots with and without the skin and then stored them at 40 degrees Centigrade (104 degrees Fahrenheit) for 4 weeks, measuring antioxidant levels and comparing them with the levels found in raw carrots.

  • The level of antioxidants in carrots that were cooked and pureed was more than three-times higher than levels measured in raw carrots.

  • They found that antioxidant levels increased by more than 34% immediately after carrots were cooked. Researchers theorize that heating softened the carrot tissue and allowed phenolics attached to the cell wall to be released.

  • Levels of antioxidants continued to rise during the first week of storage and then began to fall after 2 weeks in storage.

  • Keeping the outer skin on the carrots also boosted antioxidant activity slightly, researchers found. "Numerous phenolic compounds are located in the (skin) of fruits and vegetables, many of which are removed by peeling steps prior to processing," the study notes.

"Many consumers think that fresh vegetables are always superior in nutritional quality than processed vegetables but this does not appear to be true for carrots," Luke Howard, the study's lead author, told Reuters Health, although he stressed that additional studies are needed to determine if the antioxidants in cooked carrots are well absorbed and can prevent free radical damage.

Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 2000;48:1315-1321



Dr. Mercola Dr. Mercola's Comments:

Beta carotene is an important nutrient with many benefits. It has been clearly established that natural beta carotene, obtained from foods is far superior to synthetic beta-carotene.

However, I do believe that this study provides some deceptive information. It does appear that cooking helps to soften and breakdown the antioxidant substances to provide for better absorption. However, the lack of absorption when eating raw carrots is likely an artifact of the way most people eat. They gulp their food down and do not properly chew it.

If properly chewed, the natural process of mastication along with the enzymes present in saliva, should make the antioxidants just as digestable as cooking. This becomes increasingly difficult to do, however, in our drug-happy society, since over 600 different drugs have been shown to reduce the body production of saliva.

Additionally, juicing would bypass the absorption problem completely without compromising the integrity of the active enzymes present in the plant. One does need to exercise caution though and limit the amount of carrots one juices.

Although carrots have beta-carotene and other beneficial nutrients, they are also high in sugars and can disrupt insulin balance if consumed in excess. If you have high blood pressure, high blood cholesterol or triglycerides, extra weight, or diabetes, I would strongly advise against juicing carrots, other than maybe a very small amount added to a 'green' vegetable juice occasionally.

The consumption of carrots in significant quantities by themselves is a fairly recent phenomena. Prior to the 20th century, carrots were mainly used in parts of Europe as an ingredient in soups and stews. It was only during this past century that people began to use raw carrots in salads. In antiquity several types of carrots were grown as medicinals.

Carrots are members of the Umbelliferae family (also called the 'parsley family'), which also includes angelica, anise, caraway,celery, chervil, coriander, cumin, dill, fennel, lovage, parsley and parsnip. Some members of this family are poisonous, such as the poison hemlock.

The carrot greens, which are often discarded or used for pets, can be eaten as well and are very nutritious.

Related Articles:

Many Drugs Promote Tooth Decay By Reducing Saliva

No Benefit For Synthetic Beta Carotene

Did you find this article interesting?  Interesting Not Useful
Community Comments ( 0 )
Comment on this Article

 
Truste
 
Mercola