The man at a dinner party leans over and asks: "Are
you worried about 'mad cow' disease? Should we stop eating steak?"
I laugh. Earth to Chicken Little! The sky is not falling
on steak. Not here, anyway. Of all the things to worry about, getting
mad cow disease from a nice juicy filet mignon is not one of them. Not
yet, anyway.
I go through the obvious arguments.
Not a single case has occurred in
the United States in man or beast. Precautions are in place
to prevent the disease from spreading to this country. Feed made from
certain animals -- the suspected culprit in Europe -- is prohibited here.
Beef and beef products from affected countries are banned. Even in Europe,
fewer than 100 people have succumbed to the strange malady since the outbreak
began four years ago. Those cases have been confined to Britain, Ireland
and France where -- statistically speaking --
people are five
times more likely to be killed by a bolt of lightning than by mad cow
disease.
If you're going to worry about what you eat, there
are bigger food-borne killers. For starters, listeriosis
(from contaminated meats, dairy products, raw vegetables) and salmonella
(from contaminated raw eggs) each cause
500 deaths a year in this country. E-coli, which is most associated
with eating contaminated ground beef, kills 61 people a year. Why worry
about something that hasn't killed anybody in this country?
The expression on the dinner guest's face goes from
polite disagreement to pity. I must sound like a victim of "Animal
Farm" propaganda from the agri-medical establishment. He doesn't
believe a reassuring word I've said.
Why should he? Europe is in a panic over mad cow disease.
Overall consumption of
beef dropped 27 percent from October
to December. The cattle industry has been crushed and governments are
shaken. Instead of promoting the national staple of le steak et pommes
frites, French farmers are throwing stones at their prime minister.
The fear is spreading to these shores: Cattle in Texas
quarantined after eating bone meal. Elk in Oklahoma diagnosed with a chronic
wasting disease. Suspect mad cow candy on sale in New York City.
Mamba fruit chew, banned in Poland, is made with a
beef-based gelatin produced in Germany, where about 20 cows have been
found to be infected with bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), the
scientific name for mad cow disease. In the ensuing public-relations meltdown,
the company announced it would switch from beef gelatin to vegetable starch.
Call that Mad Cow Panic Syndrome
(MCPS) Tests have shown that the disease cannot be transmitted in gelatin,
even from infected cattle, says George Gray, director of the program for
food safety and agriculture at the Harvard School of Public Health's Center
for Risk Analysis in Boston. "It's a nonissue," he says. "This
situation takes on a life of its own."
The perception of risk
is wildly out of proportion to the actual risk.
"When I have a hamburger, I worry much more about
E-coli than a chance of BSE,"
Gray says. Even if an animal in the United States shows up sick one day,
there would be no immediate threat to people. Tightened surveillance would
prevent the spread to other animals and keep the infected animal from
reaching the human food chain. "It's not going to be a big public
health risk," Gray continues. But if that day comes, he adds, "we'll
go bonkers."
Mad cow bonkers. All of us from Henny Penny to Goosey
Loosey have a hard time dealing with risks. Certain kinds of hazards,
no matter how rare, grab our imagination so that we fear the worst. They
usually share these characteristics:
Mysterious.
Just what causes mad cow disease is not known. The prime
suspect is a prion, an aberrant protein that attacks the central
nervous system. Scientists are used to bacteria and viruses, but prions
are a new kind of infectious agent. The theory is that herds in Britain
were infected from contaminated bone meal. BSE crossed from animals to
people, causing a variant of the rare degenerative brain disorder called
Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease. There is no evidence, points out Harvard's
Gray, that the prions get into muscle meat -- in other words, into steak.
Greatest concern is focused on brain and bones and mixed meats such as
sausage.
Lethal.
The disease is horrible and invariably fatal. About 300
Americans die of the classic form of Creutzfeldt-Jakob
disease a year, which strikes seemingly at random. There is
no effective treatment. With listeriosis, for example, an estimated 2,500
Americans get very sick, but they can be treated with antibiotics and
most of them recover. Mad cow disease is a death sentence, and victims
are generally younger than those who succumb to the classic form of the
brain malady.
Unpredictable.
The infection in cattle peaked in 1993. Since then, Britain has slaughtered
infected herds and tested cattle to make sure they are healthy. Last year,
the European Union banned the use of remnant parts in animal feed to reduce
the chances of contamination. At the same time, the incubation period
in people for this disease could be anywhere from two to 20 years. Health
officials don't know if the number of cases will level off. Or whether
the current toll represents the tip of an epidemic iceberg of many more
people who harbor the infection. "We don't know how many people are
infected. We don't know the size of the risk," says psychologist
Baruch Fischhoff of Carnegie Mellon University.
There is not a lot people
can do to reduce their personal risk.
You can avoid lightning by staying indoors in a thunderstorm
(about 300 deaths in the United States annually) and prevent head injuries
on a bicycle by wearing a helmet (about 800 deaths a year). You can avoid
salmonella by cooking eggs and listeriosis by sticking to pasteurized
cheese.
But it's hard to control your exposure to all the
theoretically possible avenues to mad cow disease -- even when there is
no evidence of a problem. Just last week, the headlines screeched that
five major drug companies had used ingredients from cattle in affected
European countries to manufacture vaccines given to millions of American
children -- contrary to recommendations of the FDA. Animal-based gelatin
is also used in supplements with little government oversight.
The prions are falling! In a world of medical globalism,
neither diseases nor drugs recognize national boundaries.
To date, mad cow disease
is not a crisis in public health; but it's becoming a crisis in public
trust.
Washington
Post Tuesday, February
13, 2001; Page HE08