Diet or Exercise: Which One Works Better to Reduce Your Risk of Diabetes?

Previous Article Next Article
November 25, 2006 | 6,277 views

According to a new study by researchers examining whether a calorie-restrictive diet can extend the human lifespan, both diet and exercise provide profound benefits to reduce the risk of diabetes.

The researchers, who initially thought that exercise would produce greater benefits, examined 50 to 60 year olds whose body mass index was between 23 and 30 (at the high end of normal weight or overweight, but not obese).

The scientists were looking at diabetes development because the disease is one of the main causes of premature death.

The study participants were divided into groups and treated with either an exercise regimen or a calorie-restricted diet. All participants had their insulin action and glucose tolerance evaluated at the beginning and end of the study.

The ultimate goal of the diet group was to cut the number of calories they ate by 20 percent, while the exercise group was charged with burning 20 percent more of their calories.

Glucose tolerance and insulin levels improved to roughly the same degree in both the dieters and exercisers. Both groups also lost weight.

I've found it very interesting reviewing the number of reports that have surfaced over the past two years attempting to determine whether diet or exercise works better. I have always argued that this is not a fair question as they each are vitally important, and it will be very difficult, if not impossible in many cases, to control diabetes without using both.

It's especially interesting to me that the fitness experts who created the regimen for the exercising group prescribed 90 minutes of daily exercise, a typical treatment dosage that shows how effective treating exercise like a drug can be.

I wonder, however, if the diet group would've performed better still, had they modified their eating habits according to their body's unique nutritional type.

You may not realize that you can now comment AND vote on articles at Vital Votes. Your participation will actually help select the articles that are sent out in this newsletter. And if your comments are good enough they will be posted in the newsletter.

If you aren't registered make sure you do so resiter now at Vital Votes.  You have a chance of having your comment posted like Dr. Fielder from Scahumburg, IL,

"... what if we tried to asses which is more important to wilting plants sunlight or water?  They are both as equally necessary for a plant to express its fullest health potential ... we need to eat a metabolically sufficient diet and we need to move regularly in many dimensions through exercise. 

We have to be doing these things for ourselves continuously, there are not only the individual benefits for our system but a synergistic relationship as well.   If we eat well, move well and think well all at the same time for a period of time I think we would see a complete transformation of health.  Remember, as light returns the darkness leaves!"

 

[+]Sources and References [-]Sources and References