SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
"Convenience" Foods Don’t Really Save Time

The first academic study tracking the dinner routines of American families unearthed some surprising discoveries. It turns out that “convenience foods” don’t really save you any time in the kitchen, compared to cooking dinner from scratch.

Of the 64 weeknight dinners observed, 70 percent were home-cooked, meaning they were prepared at home, but virtually all of them included some form of packaged convenience food, such as stir-fry mixes, pre-made chicken dishes, frozen vegetables, and canned soup, for example.

Despite these conveniences, dinner wasn’t done much faster. The difference between meals involving more than 50 percent convenience foods, compared to limited use of such items (between 20 to 50 percent), was negligible. Meals still took an average of 52 minutes to prepare.

The only difference seen was the amount of time spent on hands-on preparation, where the use of convenience foods saved an average of 10 to 12 minutes.

Another interesting fact was that only three families worked from cookbooks, and no one referred to food articles from magazines while cooking.

British Food Journal July 2007; 109(7): 531-547

Eurekalert August 7, 2007

 



Dr. Mercola''s Comments Dr. Mercola's Comments:

Like the old saying goes, “you are what you eat.” You may not consider processed convenience foods as “junk,” but they are in fact not a whole lot better. Unfortunately, many of these convenience foods contain a whole host of artificial additives, flavorings, MSG, and preservatives -- none of which are beneficial to your health.

If you want to maintain good health, strive for a diet consisting of about 90 percent non-processed food, and maybe 10 percent from other food sources.  

Whole fresh foods are your best bet for benefiting your health, whether your nutritional type is protein type, carb type, or mixed type.

Why?

Because whole foods (whether meat, vegetable, or fruit) do two things, besides eliminating hunger.

First, they provide all the nutrients that nature put into the food. Whole foods contain a synergy of nutrients that work together, providing benefits that are greater than the sum of its parts. The second advantage of eating whole fresh foods is that their sheer bulk will limit the amount of chemicals and denatured food derivatives that you might otherwise fill yourself with.

One of the questions raised in the article above was “why do we rely on commercially prepared foods so heavily?” One of the potential answers they touched on was the lack of pre-planning.

Do you use a shopping list? If not, getting back into that habit might help you get back on track to a healthier lifestyle. A huge part of the problem is not knowing what you’re going to eat on Thursday night until... Thursday night. The key to getting out of that trap is to pre-plan what meals you will serve the coming week, and create a shopping list to match, so that you have all the ingredients you will need.

The first link below contains a terrific guide by Colleen Huber on how to cook with whole food, without having to quit your day job. Here are just a few of the recommendations included, which could set you free to create great, healthy meals from scratch:

    1. Once you’ve planned all your meals for the week, go to the supermarket once to purchase the whole food ingredients in one trip. Remember, when shopping for whole foods, you only need to go around the periphery of the supermarket where they are located, rather than taking time to go up and down the interior aisles where the processed foods are.

    2. Cook all your meals for the week at the same time. The trick is to cook big portions, but freeze in the smaller quantities that you and your family will eat throughout the week. 

    3. Place pre-cut vegetables in glass jars (if you evacuate the air), or in freezer bags, so you can defrost as needed during the week. One jar might contain pressed garlic with coarsely chopped string beans, which a few days from now you can sauté in coconut oil for a few minutes. 

    4. Fall in love with the crockpot all over again. It really lends itself well to a whole foods diet. Colleen Huber gives you some great tips in this article on getting the most out of this valuable appliance.

    5. During the week, defrost one of the meals you prepared on the weekend. When you’re ready to cook it, place it into a serving dish in a toaster oven rather than a microwave. Toaster ovens have major health advantages, since microwave rays are unhealthy radiation, and when you microwave in a plastic container, it drives the phthalates of the plastic right into your food, which gives an otherwise excellent meal a toxic twist that you definitely do not need.

Last, but not least, once you’ve decided to improve your health by taking charge of your food choices, remember these three essential cooking tips:

    • When you cook, use a stable oil like coconut oil (vegetable oils are easily damaged by the heat)
    • Avoid using Teflon or aluminum cookware, but if you do, never heat them to high temperatures
    • Avoid overcooking your food 

To your health -- Bon Appetit!



Related Links:



Comment on This Article Community Comments (30)
 
 
Posted On Aug 09, 2007
meh, I disagree.  Since I've cut out processed and convenience foods I know I spend more time in the kitchen.  I don't mind the extra time, but I know dinner preparation went from around 25 minutes to at least 40.  I do a lot more prep work on the weekends as well.  And cutting up a whole chicken takes a lot longer than peeling the plastic wrap off a package of boneless skinless breasts!

I'm not advocating convenience foods, but realistically you can't say that they're not...well, more convenient.  Even in the article it says that hands-on time is about 20 minutes less.

I find it amusing that they say "cooking from scratch is seen as a hobby".

Also, they didn't mention how much longer it took to clean up! :)

 
Kar_Kar
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 6/2007
Kar_Kar  
Replied

Haras
Novice User Novice User Joined On 2/2007
Haras  
 
Posted On Aug 23, 2007

Cooking from scratch doesn't take me any longer than relying on pre packaged convenience foods - just as long as I'm organised! For me that's the catch, the being organised bit.  I'm getting better and better at it.  

I do agree with you though that cleaning up after cooking from scratch takes a whole lot longer, especially if you choose not to use a water & power guzzling dishwasher.  I've turned the cleaning up part into my evening meditation - bringing order to chaos!



samurai
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 4/2007
samurai  
 
Posted On Aug 23, 2007

WHAT?  I SEE PEOPLE WAITING FOREVER IN LINE AT WENDY'S....   :)



cat56
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2006
cat56  
 
Posted On Aug 23, 2007

Kar Kar, I agree. I juice everyday for 5 of us, have a salad every day, make my own bread and burger buns(homemade pecan burgers are wonderful!) . I couldn't stand buying store bought bread of any kind because the list of ingredients was so long, and every one of them has high fructose corn syrup in them. But it definitely takes me SOOO much longer making meals. I have been eating healthy for 2 1/2 years now, and I know I spend at least 2 hours every day getting supper ready! But it is worth it!!!



K.T.
Novice User Novice User Joined On 8/2007
K.T.  
 
Posted On Aug 24, 2007

Kar_Kar what are you making? Just wondering.  I make everything from scratch (I do cheat once in a while.).  My prep work and cleanup are very short.  K.T.



analeeinmexico
Novice User Novice User Joined On 12/2006
analeeinmexico  
 
Posted On Aug 24, 2007

Cooking from scratch is much easier in larger batches.  Brown rice in the pressure cooker takes a fraction of the time it would in a normal pot.  Making multiple servings means brown rice to accompany multiple meals. Soups, chilis, caseroles, made with high quality ingredients, and frozen in portions are our own healthy form of "convenience food".  

Sarah says "I've turned the cleaning up part into my evening meditation - bringing order to chaos!"

In our houssehold, it is usually "couple time", as we talk, joke, and pat each other's behind as we pass, while putting away and wiping up. Some might call it clean foreplay  ; ) and no, we are not newlyweds.  21 years married, and still lovin' it.


 
 
 
Posted On Aug 09, 2007
Our crock pot turns every meal made in it (from mostly organic and some home-grown ingredients) into convenience food. The night before, we pile in beef and beans for chili, or chicken and veggies or what have you, refrigerate overnight, turn it on when leaving for work, and voila! a nice hot meal is ready when we get home. No processed foods, no microwaving, no worries! Plus we make enough for a lunch portion the next day, another meal made convenient. It's convenient to clean, too: just one pot. A winner.

 
ypsidixit
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 8/2007
ypsidixit  
Replied

dempoolguy
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 3/2007
dempoolguy  
 
Posted On Aug 10, 2007
Thank you. I forgot about that appliance sitting in the cupboard. I've been getting a little discouraged lately working late and coming home to a cold kitchen. Crock pot could keep my health intact during the busy season.

 
 
 
Posted On Aug 23, 2007

Anyone who finds making yogurt time consuming should get some kefir grains. Kefir is far healthier and really easy to make. It will never get as thick as most yogurts, particularly if one uses fresh goat milk as I do, but it makes a great smoothie or "yop" drink....

What I find appalling is seeing children ramming potato chips, cookies, and sugar filled junk food into themselves at recess during school time. No wonder so many teachers think these kids suffer ADD and ADHD. These "foods" are loaded with toxins and give the children sugar induced mood swings.

It amazes me that parents are so poorly educated that they don't realize that most of the "100% fruit snacks" are really just sugar with fruit flavoring....  Food producers should not be allowed to mislead people with their "made with real fruit" if the product carries more sugar than any other ingredient.

Also I've noticed these same producer changing the ingredients to fructose, sucrose, cane sugar, etc in order to modify the ingredient list to appear less sugar filled.

Parents should all be given classes to educate them what is in processed foods so their children will not suffer so much from their poor choices. My son is 7 and must read the ingredients lists before he is allowed to purchase sugar filled cereals and fruit juices. Any items with sugar in the first three items are banned from our house (this basically bans all of them from our house). He has also been taught he is lucky to have fresh fruits and carrot and pepper strips in his lunch, rather than these nasty fast food alternatives.

The addition of toys as enticements to purchase crappy food is another pet-peeve of mine. We now allow a single purchase of one toy at the end of each shopping trip (we only go to town once a month) rather than allowing our son to be bribed by these enticements in cereal, fast food restaurants, and other junk foods, essentially stripping these sellers of one brain washed individual.


 
Auntie Evil
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 7/2007
Auntie Evil  
 
 
 
Posted On Aug 09, 2007
Although I am the one preparing most of the meals, my family will participate in the preparation of dinner.  It gives me a warm "fuzzy" feeling reminding me of cooking with my grandmother.  It is a special gift to treasure and it pleases me that I am passing that on to my children.  Meals don't have to be difficult.  We eat most of our vegetables raw.  We have become very creative with our "salads". 

 
Wedgirl
Apprentice User Apprentice User, Joined On 3/2007
Wedgirl  
 
 
 
Posted On Aug 08, 2007
SLOW FOOD is nutritious and healthy and in point of fact does not take any longer to prepare that FAST or JUNK or CONVENIENT or TAKE OUT or RESTAURANT.

2/3rd's of all American meals are currently consumed outside the home, and these meals have little declaration of what is in them or how harmful it is to health.

 
Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
Replied

Kar_Kar
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2007
Kar_Kar  
 
Posted On Aug 09, 2007
2/3 of all meals seems pretty high...where is that statistic from?


Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
 
Posted On Aug 09, 2007
Brand Packaging Magazine reported it about 6 months ago.  Then Food Service Distributor Magazine announced the number as "an industry success".

Yes, it seemed HIGH to me also.

The industry 'success' would seem to be a national health disaster, as Greg Critser in FAT LAND, and many others have suggested, including the good Dr. Mercola.


Kar_Kar
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2007
Kar_Kar  
 
Posted On Aug 09, 2007
Well, in my search for more information I found this study.  Yeah it was done by the USDA, but I think it's interesting.

http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/eib19/eib19.pdf

 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.