SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
This Common Antioxidant Supplement Could Cause You Loads of Trouble

Researchers at the University of Virginia Health System have discovered troubling side effects of N-acetylcysteine (NAC), a common antioxidant used in nutritional and bodybuilding supplements.

NAC can form a red blood cell-derived molecule called nitrosothiol that fools your body into thinking there’s an oxygen shortage, which can lead to pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH).

PAH is a serious condition, where the arteries in the lungs narrow, increasing the blood pressure in your lungs, causing the right side of your heart to swell.

Lead researcher Dr. Ben Gaston, noted that this is an entirely new understanding of how oxygen is sensed by the body. As it turns out, your body responds to the nitrosothiols, which are created when a decreased amount of oxygen is carried by red blood cells -- not to the amount of oxygen dissolved in the blood.

So far, studies have only been performed on mice. The next step is to determine the threshold at which the antioxidant becomes detrimental to heart and lung function in humans.

Journal of Clinical Investigation September, 2007; 117(9):2592-601 (Free Full Text Report)

Physorg.com September 4, 2007

 



Dr. Mercola''s Comments Dr. Mercola's Comments:

N-acetylcysteine (NAC) is an acetylated amino acid and a precursor of glutathione, another potent antioxidant that prevents free radical damage from toxic exposures.

NAC is also a common emergency room treatment for people who have overdosed on acetaminophen (the active ingredient in pain relievers like Tylenol). 

Interestingly, NAC is actually used to treat several types of lung disease, and although this animal study connects it with constriction of lung arteries, at least one other study has linked NAC with improved blood flow, stating NAC might increase the biologic effects of nitric oxide by combining with it to form S-nitrosothiol, which is a potent vasodilator. They found that NAC also increases the expression of nitric oxide synthase and may thus improve blood flow as well.  

Since I don’t frequently use supplements, I consulted one of my friends, Dr. William LaValley from Austin, Texas, who is an expert in this area and has reviewed the literature thoroughly.  He successfully uses supplements as a therapeutic tool in many chronic conditions including cancer. 

He felt that PAH may be species specific and possibly won’t happen in humans, and more importantly, the study used much higher doses than are generally used in humans.  As mentioned, there are many studies supporting the anti-oxidant benefit of NAC for pulmonary function in cystic fibrosis, post-radiation, and other high oxidant conditions. His conclusion, and I agree, is that a little is probably ok - even good for you. He has used NAC liberally in his therapeutic protocols for nearly 20 years and has not observed any problems with it. However using large quantities is probably not good for you.  Long-term high doses are probably not so good for several reasons - including the possibility of PAH.  

The study says that the doses are higher than usual in humans - but we know that the supplement manufacturers have been making 500mg NAC caps and selling them by the truckload for years. My biggest concern is the use of NAC by cancer patients who think it is helping - when in fact it may be harmful to them by protecting cancer cells and counteracting what potential benefit they may get from some conventional treatments.  It's a thorny issue.

So, if used therapeutically, it should be used in low doses for 'prevention.'  High doses should be restricted to disease/stress states that have high likelihood of high reactive oxygen species generation (such as trauma, certain types of infection, malnutrition, and certain types of toxicity). 

Dr. LaValley feels that 200-500mg once a day is probably ok in most non-cancer cases. NAC is an important consideration for inclusion, at some reasonable dose, in anti-aging formulas. 

However, please remember that the best way to get your antioxidants is to make sure you’re getting them from whole foods, not from supplements, which are often isolated synthetics rather than the readily bioavailable version. What you need is the Goldilock’s equation – not too many and not too few antioxidants –  to achieve and maintain optimal health, and it is quite easy to overdose when you take supplements. Fortunately, your body does a phenomenal job of self-regulating many of these levels if you supply it with wholesome, healthy foods and limit your intake of processed foods, which are frequently loaded with artificial chemicals.  

Normalizing your insulin and leptin levels is also quite helpful, as elevated insulin and leptin levels cause absolute biochemical havoc in your body and worsen nearly every major part of your physiology. Normalizing your blood sugar will raise your glutathione levels naturally, rather than taking glutathione or precursor supplements. 

Glutathione, along with vitamin E, vitamin C and alpha lipoic acid are the basic antioxidants. Some nutritional authorities recommend you take it as a supplement, or take an NAC supplement. There are problems with both. First, the form of glutathione that works best is the reduced form, which is very difficult to absorb orally. Secondly, I advise against using NAC if you still have mercury amalgam fillings because it could interfere with the detoxification of the mercury. 

It is much better to get your glutathione through items like alpha lipoic acid that regenerates glutathione. It also has the added ability to generate other antioxidants such as vitamins C and E. The best sources of alpha lipoic acid are red meat and organ meats. Just make sure to stick with grass-fed organic meats, to get the maximum nutrient content and none of the added antibiotics or pesticides. 

Glutamine is also a useful nutrient that improves intestinal health and also serves as a direct precursor to glutathione, and some investigators believe it to be the rate-limiting nutrient for glutathione formation. However, in large quantities it can be problematic as Dr. Blaylock outlines in his book “Excitotoxins.”

 



Related Links:



Comment on This Article Community Comments (30)
 
 
Posted On Sep 06, 2007
Methinks if NAC is so bad for you we would have many more sick people from taking it than there are now.  I would take this study with a large chunk of Himalayan sea salt.

That said, I am seeing more and more evidence that whole foods and whole food supplements are much better than synthetic vitamins or isolated compounds.

We almost all ways screw up Mother Nature when we start to process food just because of the chemicals and high heat needed to do it.


 
Reesacat
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 1/2007
Reesacat  
 
 
 
Posted On Sep 10, 2007
I recently read some information taken from the Textbook of Natural Medicine at Bastyr University, that states "Up to 90% of all cancers are thought to be due to the effects of environmental carcinogens...combined with deficiencies of the nutrients the body needs for proper functioning of the detoxification and Immune systems"  My concern is how do you know if you are taking the right amount of anti-oxidants, and what about the soil content to which you live, what natural anti-oxidants are in the soil?

 
Rosey1
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 9/2007
Rosey1  
 
 
 
Posted On Sep 06, 2007
Thanks for the information PParGammaGirl,   It looks like they might use this information to develop a drug for people with Cystic Fibrosis.

Mary

 
mmc88121
Moderator User Moderator User, Joined On 11/2006
mmc88121  
 
 
 
Posted On Sep 08, 2007
Not trying to get off the subject of nac but the subject of junk supplements interests me.Like the fact that  shipping supplements in hot delivery trucks(reaching170 degrees in the summer)How can like prbotices survive this.Cold pressed oils.ect.Like to here comments.One ? Hs anybody herd of CELL FOOD .Promoted by Dr.David Dyer

 
wideurt
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 8/2007
wideurt  
Replied

Rosey1
Novice User Novice User Joined On 9/2007
Rosey1  
 
Posted On Sep 10, 2007
That is a good point. I recently worked for the postal service driving a mail truck. I can say for my area, and it works about the same for every state. I picked up mail for 5 different counties, then dropped the mail at the main postal warehouse, spent the night then picked up the processed mail and redelivered back to the post offices, the most time that the mail stayed on my truck in the heat was 1hour 40min. upon arrival at the postal warehouse mail was then unloaded, and began processing in a highly air conditioned building, in the early morning hours (3am) put back on the designated trucks, and redelivered, and not hot temperatures. In the postal routing you are on a secure route time, no stopping here or there. If you are not at your destination by a particular time, the postal service is out hunting you down. My time frame after pick up, was 1 &1/2 hr


euphrates
Novice User Novice User Joined On 7/2006
euphrates  
 
Posted On Sep 25, 2007

I have used purchase several bottles of cell food and used during several stage of my receover from an illness.

It sounds like a fabulous product but I must be honest in saying that I

didn't notice any benefit.

I have had success taking glutathione (by supplement, IV or cream) & NAC. Both have helped to lower my liver enzymes and help my body detoxify for which there was a problem.


 
 
 
Posted On Sep 29, 2007

I agree that NAC may not be safe.   However that is because of what I learned from the late Dr. Brad Cords.   He stated on a conference call that I was on that  NAC is not really a precursor to Glutathione but actually caused Glutathione in the body to concentrate in the Liver. This is what promoted the detoxification process.  But, then the rest of the body was left deficient.  He recommended bio-available Whey Protein  (especially MA Plus) to actually cause the body to produce Glutathione.   He describe it as the Master Antioxident.  In that,Glutathione controls all the other anti-oxidents in the body.  Bio-available Whey Protein provides th building blocks for Glutathione.  It is not considered a supplement but a functional food   This is because it is not a concoction or manufactured product but, a finely filtered whole food product.   I personally have experienced:  Leg pain alleviated in 3 days.   Large bumps on all of my fingers (due to Arthritus )  disappear.  Wakeup ready to  go to work rather than drag myself out of bedin the morning.  Wakeup without stuffy nose.  and, Acid reflux totally disappear in 4 months.  All these problems were eliminated in 2001 and I continue to  benefit  I know it's not he answer to eery problem but as Dr. Cords would say it was the "beginning of the answer to any health problem"  "there is nothing that it will not help"  Then you add those things that help your specific problem.  Hope I can be of help to many others.  


 
John Y
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 6/2006
John Y  
 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.