FREE Subscription
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter   
 
 
POSTED BY
February 23 2008
42,121 Views

BROWSE BY CATEGORY

Cracking Down on Organic Food Fraud

organic food, fraud, fraudulent labeling, labels, organic labels, all-natural, naturalOrganic foods are a $16 billion a year business, and some are concerned that Department of Agriculture standards and independent third-party verification may be insufficient to prevent fraud.

But Spanish scientists have developed a method of using "nitrogen isotopic discrimination" to determine if non-organic, synthetic fertilizers were used on plants. Since organic fertilizers have nitrogen isotopes that differ from synthetic fertilizers, it is possible to distinguish produce grown using the two different methods.

USDA organic standards are widely considered to be trustworthy, because independent third-party assessors check on farm practices. The USDA recently cracked down on at least one large dairy that let its standards lapse.



Dr. Mercola Dr. Mercola's Comments:

Greenwashing, the practice of branding a conventionally grown or processed food as natural or organic, is becoming a pervasive problem. If the label works, then the food inside does not actually have to be organic; an impression of organic-ness is all that is required to partake in the organic goldmine.

Since true organic produce should be grown without synthetic or otherwise toxic fertilizers, being able to introduce a testing procedure that can produce reliable and verifiable results would go a long way to ensure that you’re actually getting what you believe you’re paying for. Unfortunately, as this article states, it may take a while before this method can be put to use on a wide scale, due to costs.

Until then, your best bet is still to be an informed consumer, if not a bit of a sleuth, and do your homework before buying.  

Think About It – Does the Label Make Sense? 

I’ve already warned readers about the substandard and distorted image of organic foods promoted by companies such as Wal-Mart. Last year, fraud investigators found Wal-Mart guilty of deceptive organic labeling on several products, including Silk Soy Milk and Florida Crystals Natural Sugar, as well as various fresh produce items.

Some advertising experts have expressed the belief that the organic trend may soon be coming to an end, especially with the wake-up call of products like NATURAL Cheetos hitting grocery store shelves.

The question you need to ask yourself is this: Does the label really make sense? Is it possible for Cheetos to be processed and still be considered a natural health food?

Believe me, the day you see “Organic Cheetos” in your grocery store you can kiss the value of the term “organic” goodbye. It will be absolutely worthless as a marker of healthy food, and merely serve as another manipulation tool to deceive the public and take more money from you for unhealthy products.

Other major corporations like Dean Foods, General Mills, Unilever, Mars, Kraft and Kellogg have also jumped in to reap some of the fat margins that are present in organic foods, further distorting the real meaning of organic, and all-natural.

If You Can’t Trust Them, Avoid Them

The trend of organic fraud may linger for years before enough consumers begin to demand to know more about the food products they buy.

Until then, your only solution is to seek out LOCAL suppliers of healthy food where you can actually get to know the people who are growing your food. A good start is to check out some of the suppliers I mentioned in my previous article, How to Get Inexpensive, Organic, Locally-Grown Vegetables.

Always remember, just because someone slaps an organic label on a food product, that label does not somehow magically transform a junk food into a health food. “Organic” sugar and “all-natural” processed foods are every bit as pernicious to your health as conventional sugar and processed foods.


Related Articles:

Did you find this article interesting?  Interesting Not Useful
Community Comments ( 55 )
Comment on this Article
  
  
pameladragon
[ Joined on 04/07 ] [ Posted on February 23, 2008 ]
17 Points        
   
 
Novice User

We raise most of our own food, meat and veggies, and even make our own soap, beer, and wine.  What we can't/don't raise we get from friends who do.  But the USDA is trying to make it impossible for little guys to raise their own meat and if the National Animal Identification System (NAIS) is allowed to become mandatory, it will be impossible to find free-range eggs, chicken, beef, etc.  Their tracking and premises I.D. requirements will put all small producers out of business.  You can kiss raw milk, farmstead cheeses, free-range poultry and eggs good-by forever.  Call your Congressmen and Senators and talk to your state representatives, NAIS will force us all to eat heavily processed, mass-produced food!

 [ Reply ]
  
  
foxtroter_203
[ Joined on 09/06 ] [ Posted on February 6, 2008 ]
13 Points        
   
 
Savvy User
I just make sure all my organic food comes from China and then I know I am safe and protected.  (Darn Tongue stuck)
 [ Reply ]
Mercola
  
Russ Bianchi
[ Joined on 09/06 ]  [ Posted on February 6, 2008]
5 Points        
   
Savvy User
  Mercola
USDA ORGANIC certification or standards are a FRAUD!

Argumentation that self-appointed for profit Organic Certification regional and national fidedoms are any better is also pure ripe fermenting organic BULL excrement. 

If you totaled the personnel to certify all seeds, soils, crops, and products labeled 'organic' in natural health food stores and supermarkets in the USA today, not even 15% could possibly be truly organic, on the lack of personnel to do the copious work alone. 

Argumentation from American Organic Certifiers that they have implemented self-auditing programs among producers is also a FRAUD. 

This is a piece of paper for large bribe money business, in MANY, if not the vast majority, of cases, with NO empirical uniform code of regulation in the USA.

The true inspection and enforcement UK Soils Association standards for 'organic', to the letter, in that country, far exceed the money for paper business in America.

Who suffers?  Consumers being RIPPED-OFF at higher prices for no value in better nutrition or safety.

What remains outrageous to me is that the so-called natural health food industry, claiming to really want to help both food safety, and improve nutrition, for consumers, is among the LARGEST violators of such standards, including but not limited to fraudulent ingredient labeling, on a regular basis, and simply LYING about better quality, at higher prices (alla 'WHOLE PAYCHECK') where little or no empirically improvement exists.

It's as if Big Tobacco & Big Pharma were now running the natural health food chains...maybe they are? 

At least in fast and junk food you KNOW there is now pretense of quality for higher prices....
Mercola
  
miragemama
[ Joined on 06/07 ]  [ Posted on February 7, 2008]
11 Points        
   
Apprentice User
  Mercola
Well with cancer drugs found in tap water now, at least you have a head start with your "treatment", since those toxic veggies from China surely will fuel some form of cancer within you.....LOL!
Mercola
  
"B"
[ Joined on 11/07 ]  [ Posted on February 22, 2008]
       
   
Novice User
  Mercola

Is that the same China that puts lead into our children's toys and poisons our pet food with chemical?  Huh?  Huh?

Mercola
  
Pat Ormsby
[ Joined on 06/06 ]  [ Posted on February 23, 2008]
1 Points        
   
Savvy User
  Mercola

Actually, my husband reacts badly to the pesticides that are normally used on peanuts, but when he tried organic peanuts from China, he found them to be okay.  It appears to us that the Chinese organic growers are being honest, at least in this case.  In Japan, meanwhile, where trustworthiness is an important virtue, we've had such a rash of fraudulent labeling recently that the Buddhist monk who decided from a number of entries what letter (kanji) would represent the year 2007 selected "gi," meaning "deceit," and termed it a particularly shameful year.  For all my efforts to eat only fresh, unprocessed foods, I continue to have minor health problems which clear up when I go abroad.  So, I hat to say it, but watch out for Japan, too.

Mercola
  
Shazam1
[ Joined on 02/08 ]  [ Posted on February 23, 2008]
       
   
Novice User
  Mercola

I think I would be more skeptical of China...  How do we know for sure?...

Mercola
  
K.T.
[ Joined on 08/07 ]  [ Posted on February 24, 2008]
       
   
Novice User
  Mercola

Foxtroter I hope your darn tongue did stick!

  
  
Beccadog
[ Joined on 10/07 ] [ Posted on February 23, 2008 ]
12 Points        
   
 
Apprentice User

If you are considering throwing in the towel on food labeled as "organic", even USDA organic, consider this:

chemical fertilizer in the USA had the weakest regulations compared to other countries in the world that regulated fertilizer.  And, the regulations that were in place prior to this administration, only came about after Duff Wilson, an investigative reporter previously with the Seattle Times, had uncovered what became an award winning series entitled Fear in the Fields.  Wilson uncovered that legally hazardous wastes went into the silos as hazardous waste but magically came out as fertilizer.

His articles are still in the archives at the Seattle Times, but here is an article by Seattles Times reporter, Tom Brown that I happen to have found.

The date was Wednesday, July 23, 1997, and the article (in the Business section) was entitled:

Food Processors Ask State For Regulations On Toxins In Fertilizer - - Industrial Waste Puts `Public Trust' At Risk

**An association of 75 Northwest food-processing companies wants Washington state to regulate the practice of using industrial-waste products - some of which contain toxic substances - in the production of fertilizer....

"The Northwest Food Processors Association believes that the practice of using industrial byproducts to produce fertilizer should be regulated by the departments of Ecology and Agriculture," said Smith's July 17 memo to Pendowski. "While using industrial byproducts may serve an environmentally sound purpose, these products should meet a risk-based standard prior to being licensed for sale." ...

In stories July 3 and 4, The Seattle Times reported that fertilizers are so poorly regulated that substances containing such hazardous materials as cadmium, lead, arsenic, radioactive elements and dioxins are sometimes included in their manufacture...**

archives.seattletimes.nwsource.com/.../display

 [ Reply ]
Mercola
  
Islander
[ Joined on 03/07 ]  [ Posted on February 23, 2008]
5 Points        
   
Moderator User
  Mercola

Beccadog, your informative posts are a refreshing change from the anecdotal personal experiences and knee-jerk rants. Your contributions are a valuable addition to this site!

Mercola
  
Charisse
[ Joined on 10/07 ]  [ Posted on February 25, 2008]
       
   
Apprentice User
  Mercola

yes, thank you beccadog!

  
  
mmc88121
[ Joined on 11/06 ] [ Posted on February 6, 2008 ]
10 Points        
   
 
Moderator User
While the test is interesting, I doubt that the U.S.D.A. would be interested in a test that might bring hazardous practices to light.  They would not be able to get the money they need from the farmers to stay certified.

Mary
 [ Reply ]
  
  
garden1sass
[ Joined on 02/08 ] [ Posted on February 23, 2008 ]
8 Points        
   
 
Novice User

I am currently trying to establish a CSA (Community Supported Ag) and Co-op here in my neighborhood.  With this background and experience I can tell you that most folks would rather know where and how their food is grown as opposed to it just having the "organic" label.  For a small operation to become "certified organic" is the equivalent, in my opinion, of a special individualized gov. tax  (fee charged for that cert.) which once paid will give the operator back their constitiutional right to freedom of speech, allowing them to use the word "organic" when descibing their growing practices without fear of being fined if caught using that word without gov. certificaton!  Now how free is that speech? I hope most people wise up to the fact that they are responsible for the food they consume and if they want REAL food, then do the homework and find the people who want to provide it in your neck of the woods.  There is no substitute for personal responsibility on the consumers part and there is no gov cert. that is automatically going to make a grower "organic".  It is actions, not words!!  I fear we will just be left with gov. looking for additiional ways to collect more of our hard earned pay, while telling us they are actually trying to ensure our safety and serve us and the additional fee's are 'the cost' of it all.  "Government that governs the least, governs the best." .... Ok, I'll step down off my soap box now.  I need to go start some plants from heirloom seeds so that my family can eat this coming winter.  Which by the way....90% of what my family ate this winter was from what I managed to 'put up' last summer as far as vegetables, fruit and meat, (canned, dried, frozen and root cellared)-hoping to get one cow someday.  To sum it up, I may be a bit preachy here but I do practice what I preach.

 [ Reply ]
Mercola
  
annapaloma
[ Joined on 06/06 ]  [ Posted on February 25, 2008]
       
   
Novice User
  Mercola

Good for you! I am on my way to food sovereignty as well.  Life sure is a lot

simpler!  What I eat us simple and from scratch and tasty.  I am enjoying this journey and have a greater appreciation for food.  Great post.  Thanks.

  
  
shaneperrone
[ Joined on 11/07 ] [ Posted on February 7, 2008 ]
8 Points        
   
 
Apprentice User
Everyone got their hands in my pants! (for my wallet of course)
Business's want to get money any way they can, and they will follow it even if it means a bit of shaddy dealing.
 [ Reply ]
  
  
Beccadog
[ Joined on 10/07 ] [ Posted on February 23, 2008 ]
6 Points        
   
 
Apprentice User

Trust not the Bush-Cheney USDA, EPA, FDA, Department of Interior or anything else that corporate lobbyists have been appointed to in government by the Bush-Cheney Administration.  Everything coming out of this administration is FRAUD and deception!  

However, there is still some organic food that is organic produced.  And, it may even be organically produced in China.  It's just that there are no regulations in China, to my knowledge, and the regulations that were once in place in the USA were based on peer reviewed science, something that the Bush Administration does not support.  They only support vested interest science by the lobbyists of industries and not the organic production industry.

Right after the Bush Administration took over the White House, long-time staffers that did not support the new agenda were fired and replaced with corporate lobbyists.  First to go were at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, but also Bush appointed a Dow Chemical lobbyist to the National Institutes of Health. At the NIH, I noticed (because I'm in there often) that all the subtitled had been cleared of citations (at the Hazardous Substances Data Banks) and obviously non-scientific data was put in its place. When Bush science was added, it all predated the Clinton Administration, that is, studies were published during the Reagan-Bush and Bush Quayle administrations, with no new findings published.

Suddenly toxic formaldehyde, a human carcinogen, no longer caused cancer in humans, according to the overall of the data base by industry lobbyists.  And there is more, but it will take a long time to locate citations that attest to what I'm writing.

 [ Reply ]
Mercola
  
Islander
[ Joined on 03/07 ]  [ Posted on February 23, 2008]
3 Points