SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
Carcinogens Found in "Organic" Personal Care Products

body lotion, personal care productsA new study commissioned by the Organic Consumers Association (OCA) found that many leading "natural" and "organic" brand shampoos, body washes, and lotions contain the carcinogenic contaminant 1,4-Dioxane.

1,4-Dioxane is considered a chemical "known to the State of California to cause cancer.” It is a byproduct of the cancer-causing petrochemical Ethylene Oxide, which is used as part of a short-cut process called Ethoxylation, which makes harsh ingredients milder.

1,4-Dioxane is also suspected of being a kidney toxicant, neurotoxicant and respiratory toxicant, among others, according to the California EPA. It is also a leading groundwater contaminant.

Some of the leading organic and natural brands found to contain 1,4-Dioxane include:
  • JASON Pure Natural & Organics
  • Giovanni Organic Cosmetics
  • Kiss My Face
  • Nature’s Gate Organics
To avoid 1,4-dioxane, OCA recommends reading ingredient labels and avoiding products with indications of ethoxylation, which include: "myreth," "oleth," "laureth," "ceteareth," any other "eth," "PEG," "polyethylene," "polyethylene glycol," "polyoxyethylene," or "oxynol," in ingredient names.

Sources:

Dr. Mercola''s Comments Dr. Mercola's Comments:

I know you may be tempted to throw up your hands in dismay that even your natural and “organic” soaps, body lotions, cosmetics, and shampoos may be harmful, but there are some safe personal care products on the market.

And once you know what to look for, and perhaps more importantly, what to avoid, finding them is not that difficult.

Beware of “Greenwashed” Personal Care Products

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration does not require companies to test their personal care products for safety. What this means is that anyone can throw together a medley of chemicals, add a bit of synthetic fragrance, and call it a body lotion. Yes, this is also true for products that are labeled “natural” and even “organic.”

Now let me say this again: cosmetics and their ingredients do not have to undergo any type of approval process before hitting store shelves, and the terms “natural” and “organic” have no definitions. In other words, when it comes to cosmetics labeling, it’s a free for all.

Some products may include a few organic ingredients, for instance, along with several chemical ones -- and still claim to be natural or organic on the label.

 Of course, organic personal care items have been all the rage recently, and sales of organic personal care items reached $350 million in 2007, increasing 24 percent from 2005.

But if you read Tuesday’s newsletter, then you know that giant corporations are often behind popular organic products. And many of these products are greenwashed to make them appear natural and healthy on the outside, when in reality they contain synthetic ingredients that can harm your health, like 1,4-Dioxane.

Ingredients to AVOID in Your Personal Care Products

You wouldn’t knowingly rub a bunch of chemicals on your skin, would you? Well, that’s often what happens every day when people slather on lotion, apply makeup or wash their hair. Is using a typical body lotion for a day going to kill you? Well, of course not.

But every product that you put on your body gets absorbed directly into your bloodstream. And over time these chemicals add a significant burden to your body, and that burden can manifest into disease.

So when choosing your personal care products, keep in mind that the ingredients should be safe enough to eat, since that is essentially what you are doing when you apply something onto your skin.

Yet, even if you did happen to eat these chemicals, your digestive system can produce specific enzymes to break down these toxins and excrete them … something that doesn’t readily occur when you absorb them through your skin. So you really do need to be careful.

The only way to be sure of what’s in your personal care products is to become familiar with which ingredients to avoid, and then check the labels of every product before you buy it. Here are some of the major ones that you will definitely want to avoid:
  • Paraben, a chemical found in underarm deodorants and other cosmetics that has been shown to mimic the action of the female hormone estrogen, which can drive the growth of human breast tumors.
  • Phthalates, plasticizing ingredients (present in nearly three-quarters of 72 products tested by the Environmental Working Group), which have been linked to birth defects in the reproductive system of boys and lower sperm-motility in adult men, among other problems.
  • Musks, used as fragrances, can accumulate in your body, and have been linked to skin irritation, hormone disruption, and cancer in laboratory studies.
  • Artificial fragrances, which are among the top five known allergens, and can cause asthma and trigger asthma attacks.
  • Methylisothiazolinone (MIT), a chemical used in shampoo to prevent bacteria from developing, which may have detrimental effects on your nervous system.
  • Toluene, made from petroleum or coal tar, and found in most synthetic fragrances. Chronic exposure linked to anemia, lowered blood cell count, liver or kidney damage, and may affect a developing fetus.
  • Mineral Oil, Paraffin, and Petrolatum, these products coat your skin like plastic, clogging pores and creating a build-up of toxins. They also slow cellular development, which can cause you to show earlier signs of aging, and are a suspected cause of cancer and disruption to hormonal activity.
This is only a sampling of the toxic ingredients that are out there. If you are wondering whether your favorite personal care products are safe, the Environmental Working Group’s Skin Deep Cosmetic Safety Database allows you to look up a product and find out.

Or Better Yet, Use Only Products With Ingredients That You Can Read and Pronounce

This is probably the simplest way to find safe products out there. If it includes a lot of long, complex ingredient names, it’s probably not safe.

Fortunately, your search for safe skin care may soon get a lot easier. I am proud to report that my team has been researching this topic extensively and we are getting very close to launching one of the best, most pure skin care product lines out there. It is truly effective, has absolutely no synthetic ingredients, and is packaged in brown glass bottles.

But for now, we’re talking about your health here, so please do be choosy and only use products made of real, recognizable, natural and organic ingredients.


Related Links:



Comment on This Article Community Comments (124)
 
 
Posted On Mar 20, 2008
After looking up the ingredients in my so-called natural products and discovering that there were lots of unnatural chemicals in them, we decided to make our own soap. The only main ingredients are:  fats, lye and water. My daughter decided to add cocoa powder for a chocolate scent. Then, she used the soap to make shampoo by adding extra water and used pectin to make it thicker. She followed a recipe in a soap  making book we have.  My son found a recipe for hair gel on the internet that only uses flax seed and water.  It works extremely well and only takes minutes to make.  If we all get back to the basics and learn to make a lot of our own products, we won't need to worry about what corporations put in their products.  In addition to having better products, we will save money.  In the future, we are even going to try to make our own lye.  You make it by running water through wood ash. Since we heat with wood, we have plenty of wood ash laying around.

 
libertyinmo
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 3/2008
libertyinmo  
Replied

sobber
Novice User Novice User Joined On 10/2007
sobber  
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

ladies please stop using anything on your faces and bodies ; men hate colored,scented,refurbished faces and bodies ; period.



Barbiec1953
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2006
Barbiec1953  
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

Dear Sobber, I hope, fot the most part, what you say is true.

I am a woman but it distresses me to see people reconfiguring

their bodies in such a drastic way.  I understand if you are

disfigured... but to erase some things that are your genetic

background sends a wrong message to our chidren... what you

are intrinsicly is ugly and you need to change it to something

else.  And the breast implants, to me, are so blatently ugly

and obvious.  Why would you want to attract someone who is

attracted to your huge chest ?  What if they ended up leaking

and/or disfiguring you... would he stay with you once they're

gone from that or a mastectomy ?  It's scary to think we've

been bewitched by such shallow things.



snowburn5
Novice User Novice User Joined On 7/2006
snowburn5  
 
Posted On Apr 06, 2008

Sobber, its cute how you assume most women use "anything" on our faces and bodies for men.  I moisturize my skin so it doesn't itch, stretch, or cause me discomfort. I scent it with lavender because it soothes me. Not because I'm trying to impress men who aren't worth impressing, especially when they assume all my hard work of slathering on this and that is for their enjoyment.  

Use what you will or won't on your body, and leave others to their own.  And don't flatter yourself, its not for you.



LadyPam
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 2/2008
LadyPam  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

Liberyinmo, this is great that you're making your own. I'd be careful making my own lye as you then don't have a standardised strength and, as you know, soapmaking can be dangerous. But I'm sure you're well informed. I'm surprised you have to add anything to THICKEN soap - unless your lye is potassium hydroxide (used for making liquid soap) instead of the more usual sodium hydroxide.



pbpace
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2006
pbpace  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

Wow snowburn5! You sound very angry! I have to agree with Sobber. Most women I know wear makeup to impress either men or women.


 
 
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

Use Dr. Bronner's.  It is USDA certified organic.  I use it for everything.  Washing hair, face, body.  I even use it for cleaning. It is the only soap that I have found that is great for my children's sensitive skin. The almond-hemp 18-1 is great for hard wood floors, cleaning sinks, drains, stains in clothing, my carpet, and I even use it on my dog.  Plus, you'll get a kick out of reading the label on the entire bottle.


 
wesme01
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 10/2007
wesme01  
Replied

eatreal
Novice User Novice User Joined On 2/2008
eatreal  
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

Dr. Bronner's is Fair Trade too. My favorite home cleaning soap is the Sal Suds. Balsalm Fir Oil makes it smell awesome (not overwhelming or fake pine-sol like at all) and it work greats as a dish soap and a hand soap too.

Did you know that the FDA allows up to 10ppm dioxane in foods? While Dr. Mercola states that eating it may be "sort of" safer than absorbing it through the skin, I have to say that the OCA really ought to blow the lid off the exposure to this in processed foods, too.



Barbara M
Novice User Novice User Joined On 4/2007
Barbara M  
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

Dr. Bronner's is the greatest. Why would anyone use anything else?



ToothChick
Novice User Novice User Joined On 12/2007
ToothChick  
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

I love Dr. Bronner's!  The almond is my favourite.... Don't use the peppermint soap 'down there'! =)



nast
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2006
nast  
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

Dr.Bronner's has simply the best products.  I have been using it for everything.  Sal suds is wonderful for all house cleaning- from dishes to laundry. The soaps are mild and wonderful even for newborns



LaurenBW
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2007
LaurenBW  
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008

Sal Suds contains sodium lauryl sulfate.



Joan Courtenay
Novice User Novice User Joined On 1/2007
Joan Courtenay  
 
Posted On Apr 10, 2008

My husband and I have used Dr. Bonner's bar soap for years. He has sensitive skin so he uses the Baby soap bar while I love the Lemon soap bar. We tried Dr. Bonner's liquid soaps and shampoo but didn't like their odor. However, their bar soaps fragrances are subtle and very pleasant. As far as we're concerned there's nothing like Dr. Bonner's bar soap and we tried just about everything. Also, Burt's Bees products are very good. Their lip balm is the best, as are their lip stains.

Also, thanks to Dr. Mercola and others for outing Jason's and Kiss my Face, I was always uncomfortable with their attention to marketing. They're everywhere.


 
 
 
Posted On Apr 06, 2008

First of all, "everything on your skin" does NOT get "directly" absorbed into your bloodstream. Or even reach your bloodstream at all. Most things do NOT. That is the purpose of skin, it's a barrier. Anyone here with a first year Biology course knows that. Most molecules are far too large to be absorbed through skin. Think about it...if that was the case, yes, that ONE time of touching body lotion with chemicals would have put you in the hospital or killed you. Things like Nicotine patches are *designed* to work the way they do by Pharmaceutical companies...I doubt anyone who makes shampoo wants to do the same. They want to  keep you as a customer, not kill you.

People are breathing in toxic fumes from inside and outside every day. Is your paint in your home organic? Your flooring? Your sheets? Your clothing?

While there is nothing wrong with wanting to buy only organic beauty products, I personally think that food is where you should put your money instead.  Grow your own if you can.

Sensationalist claims that are UNPOVEN and FALSE make Americans look dumb. That's the last thing Americans need...information from a "alternative" source doesn't make it correct either.

I agree with Mercola on many things, and like him a lot, but he's got to stop making unproven claims in order for most of us with education to take him seriously. He's so right on the money with some things, so out there with others. I wish he'd walk a straighter line so he gets the respect he deserves.


 
Curious26
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 2/2008
Curious26  
Replied

LadyPam
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 2/2008
LadyPam  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

Curious26, thanks for this. I get a bit tired of this "Everything gets absorbed" nonsense as well.

However, some things DO get absorbed, among them nasties like sodium laurel sulphate; it does have a molecular size small enough to get through the skin, and it accumulates in vital organs. It's in mainstream 'soaps' (even many solid bars that customers believe to be soap - they're NOT soap, they're hardened detergents!), shower gels, shampoos and toothpastes. It's even in some popular moisturisers - heaven knows why! - and some medicines.



chantalrossking
Novice User Novice User Joined On 3/2008
chantalrossking  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

sounds like to me you went to the same school as the doctors who have love affairs with the bid pharma. Being ignorant is not going to get you anywhere, I am sure your education has tought you that your sj=kin is your largest organ and what you would not eat you should not put on your skin.



HeatherM
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2006
HeatherM  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

Curious26, I agree with everything you said, including your Dr. Mercola opinion. I also have decided to spend my money on quality food, a water purifier  & some supplements, rather than organic body products, because they are so expensive & I feel I achieve more with everything else I'm doing for my health.

Also, food products on the skin can breed bacteria, so their appplication can have a down side.



OrganicSkin
Novice User Novice User Joined On 2/2007
OrganicSkin  
 
Posted On Apr 09, 2008

I saw a programme on TV lstt week that was studying the possible reason for the reduction in sperm count and increased numbers of deformed sperm in men over the past 50 years. There was a strong inference to the presence of toxic chemicals in waterways and personal care products in particular. They did an experiment where they put body cream that was known to contain pthalates in it, over the bodies of men and tetsed to see if and when the pthalates were present in the blood stream. They were there within one hour!

Whether or not personal care items actually make it into the blood steam or not they go somewhere. Creams that are absorbed are going to be absorbed into the tissues and the blood stream if particles are small enough and many of the nasty ones are. These chemicals being present in the tissues of the body are just as much of a concern as those in the blood stream.

Some parts of the body absorb more than others too, like the scalp and underarms that have large hair follicles. As an example a 2004 UK study detected traces of five parabens in the breast cancer tumours of 19 out of 20 women studied.  This small study does not prove a causal relationship between parabens and breast cancer, but it is important because it detected the presence of intact parabens -- unaltered by the body’s metabolism -- an indication of the chemicals’ ability to penetrate skin and remain in breast tissue.

It's seriously not worth the risk.

The only guarantee that personal care products are safe is that they are certifed organic to food standards. This is because organic cosmetic standards are not worth the paper they are written on. Currently Miessence from ONE Group provides the world's most extensive range of cetrifed organic personal care items and cosmetics AND they are CO to food standards.



cjh
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
cjh  
 
Posted On Jul 10, 2008

You could not have said it better. Dr. Mercola is certainly right on the money with some things and way out in left field with others. Seaotter


 
 
 
Posted On Mar 18, 2008
I just started to use a soap by Kiss My Face, it's made with olive oil mostly but i did'nt notice any dioxane in the list of ingredients. I'll check again and if they do they might as well be called "KISS MY BUT-"

 
seg
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 11/2006
seg  
Replied

bmc
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 2/2007
bmc  
 
Posted On Mar 18, 2008
FYI   I may have read the article wrong, but it sounded like Dioxane is a by- product, so it may not be on the ingredients list. If you don't see Dioxane you might look for Ethylene Oxide instead.


qualitygeek
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 10/2007
qualitygeek  
 
Posted On Mar 18, 2008
I have pretty much only used carmex or burt's bees lip balms for years - I don't wear cosmetics in general...looks like my carmex supply is going into the trash as soon as I can track all the tubes down...

I'm scared to check my soap, shampoo, etcetera


wassily
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 4/2007
wassily  
 
Posted On Mar 22, 2008
Scrutinize that blog post - dioxane (dioxin?) isn't an ingredient - it's a by-product generated by one of the ingredients.  I think someone said in a post some time ago - if you can't pronounce an ingredient, don't buy it!


evihcra
Novice User Novice User Joined On 4/2008
evihcra  
 
Posted On Apr 06, 2008

Kiss My Face Olive Oil Soap only lists: Soponified Olive Oil, water and Sodium Chloride.  So I am guessing that it is pretty pure - as far as soaps go, tho I don't have a clue what Sodium Chloride is.



LadyPam
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 2/2008
LadyPam  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

Evihcra, I try to not be quick to judge but... how can you be interested in nutrition and health and NOT know that sodium chloride is common table salt?

I can't help wondering why a manufacturer would put that in a soap. From the ingredients listed, it IS actually soap and not a detergent (saponified means the oil, which is acid, has been neutralised by a strong alkaline, usually sodium hydroxide lye, leaving a salt dissolved in water, which is soap).



c.j.
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 3/2007
c.j.  
 
Posted On Apr 09, 2008

While some of kiss may Face has some lower amounts of these things they are not to the limit of regular soaps etc.They are very minmal compared to many other brands. Use the Sudz line if you want a quality product without much of the carcegins. The whitening toothpaste they have is one of the most natural one I have found. And not all of the products have them in there, they are also derived from natural sources unlike the manmade counterparts of other brands.

While I agree that you need to stay as natural as possible, I do believe that the amounts in KMF is extremely low comapared to otherr brands.


 
 
 
Posted On Apr 05, 2008
This post was deleted because it violated our Terms Of Use :
Submit stories or comments linking to affiliate programs, multi-level marketing schemes, or off-topic content or any other system that will result in your personal financial or commercial gain.

 
Meadow
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 4/2008
Meadow  
Replied

jgeno
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2007
jgeno  
 
Posted On Apr 06, 2008

I went on the web site for miessence.  It's all nice and everything, but the prices are outrageous!  Why does certified organic have to cost so much?  To me it's a total rip off.  There has to be a company out there that offers certified organic skin care products at a price that won't knock your socks off!  Anybody out there know of one???  



LadyPam
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 2/2008
LadyPam  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

jgeno, the reason MiEssence products are so grossly inflated in price is because it's an MLM - a multi level marketing company.  I am surprised that the moderators here have not deleted all this spamming for business! In early days, MLMs offered tiny discounts to distributors and small bonusses for moving quite a lot of product. These days, in order to attract distributors, all these companies keep offering bigger and better bonusses.

The ONE group (MiEssence) now gives (I think) 30% discount (= mark-up) to frontline distributors and fairly hefty bonusses for recruiting active (= regularly ordering) distributors under you, plus large bonusses for the big, successful players. They are the same players who have made big money in all other MLMs; this is the way you build your market with the MLM model.

MiEssence products are just ludicrous in price. £28 (over $50 or AU$60) is just ridiculous for a shampoo; you're better off not washing your hair at all, except with plain water - look up some sites about this.

If that's too radical, do some searches for safe products. There are better alternatives at a tiny fraction of the price: e.g. Mercola's own Natural Skin Butter at around a QUARTER the price of a MiEssence equivalent; you can use it as a cleanser, as well.



aemit
Novice User Novice User Joined On 8/2007
aemit  
 
Posted On Apr 07, 2008

To LadyPam: My guess is that why the MiEssence posts are not deleted is because they ARE after all organic and despite the price, are convenient to order even from abroad, anyway that's not such a major factor but when it comes to ingredients, they are additive-free. However, I would be happy if there were more suggestions from readers from other (not MLM) companies, like someone here just mentioned Terressentials.com and the prices there seem to be quite reasonable! And they seem to ship to foreign countries too so I might just order some stuff from them.


 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.