Hide this
 

Bag Wars -- Paper vs Plastic: The Real Truth

November 06, 2008 | 82,711 views
Share This Article Share

"Paper or plastic?" It seems like it should be an easy choice, but from durability and reusability to life cycle costs, there's a lot more to each bag than meets the eye.

Paper comes from trees -- lots and lots of trees. The trees are found, marked and felled in a process that all too often involves clear-cutting, resulting in massive habitat destruction and long-term ecological damage. It takes approximately three tons of wood chips to make one ton of pulp. The pulp is washed and bleached, and both stages require thousands of gallons of clean water.

If you throw them away, they'll eventually break down over many, many years. But if you choose to recycle the paper bags, then things get a little tricky. The paper must first be re-pulped, which usually requires a chemical process involving compounds like hydrogen peroxide, sodium silicate and sodium hydroxide, which bleach and separate the pulp fibers.

Unlike paper bags, plastic bags are typically made from oil, a non-renewable resource. Plastics are a by-product of the oil-refining process, accounting for about four percent of oil production around the globe. Like paper, plastic can be recycled, but it isn't simple or easy. Recycling involves essentially re-melting the bags and re-casting the plastic.

According to a life cycle analysis, plastic bags create fewer airborne emissions and require less energy per 10,000 equivalent uses. But paper bags can hold more stuff per bag -- anywhere from 50 percent to 400 percent more, depending on how they're packed, since they hold more volume and are sturdier.

Ultimately, neither paper nor plastic bags are the best choice; choosing reusable canvas bags instead is the way to go. From an energy standpoint, canvas bags are 14 times better than plastic bags and 39 times better than paper bags!

 

Dr. Mercola's Comments:

Did you know that, worldwide, we use an estimated one million plastic bags each minute? Somewhere between 500 billion to 1 trillion plastic bags are used and discarded EVERY year. Of those, only 1 percent or so are recycled – at a cost higher than what it would cost to produce a brand new one.

The rest ends up in landfills, in our oceans, and as litter strewn across the globe. Plastic bag litter can now be found as far north as Spitsbergen (78° North latitude), and as far south as the Falklands (51° South latitude). 

The first plastic “baggies” for bread, sandwiches, fruits, and vegetables were introduced in the United States in 1957. By the late 1960s plastic trash bags started appearing in homes and along curbsides around the world. It’s hard to believe that in just 50-some years our thoughtless consumption has managed to turn parts of our oceans into a plastic concoction that now contains six times more plastic by weight than plankton!

Plastic Bags are Forever

Many people don’t realize that plastic bags don’t biodegrade. They photodegrade, slowly breaking down into smaller and smaller toxic bits, which contaminate soil and waterways, where it enters the food chain - as animals mistake these tiny bits and pieces for food. 

While plastic left in the sun on land can absorb infrared heat, which helps this process along, plastic in water takes far longer. Worse yet, even though the “ghostlike fishnet” made from photodegradable plastic might disintegrate before it drowns a dolphin, its chemical nature will not change for perhaps thousands of years. The filter feeders of the oceans will still ingest it.

Except for a small amount of plastic that has been incinerated, every single bit of plastic manufactured in the last 50+ years still remains somewhere in the environment.  That half-century’s total production has already surpassed 1 billion tons.

Additionally, it takes 11 barrels of oil to produce one ton of plastic bags, which means we’ve used up some 11 billion barrels of a non-renewable resource to satisfy our want for convenience.

This plastic pollution causes more than 1 million seabirds, 100,000 marine mammals, and even more fish to die in the North Pacific alone, every year. And, let’s not forget, it’s not just marine animals that are poisoned by all this plastic. You too are now ingesting plastics every day, and being exposed to a potentially deadly mix of plastic chemicals and additives, including:

  • Cancer-causing PFOAs
  • PBDEs, which cause reproductive problems
  • The reproductive toxins, phthalates
  • BPA, which disrupts your endocrine system by mimicking the female hormone estrogen

What happens to your body when you breathe, eat, drink, and absorb all of this plastic? Obesity, declining fertility rates and other reproductive problems, cancer, and more.

Why Switching to Paper is FAR From the Best Solution

While switching to paper might appear to be better than sticking with plastic, paper also, unfortunately, comes at a very high price to your environment, and your health. In fact, they’re roughly equal in their number of pros and cons. For example:

    1. Producing a paper bag requires more than four times as much energy than it does to produce a plastic bag.

      A plastic bag uses 594 BTUs, compared to a paper bag, which uses 2511 BTUs during the manufacturing process.
      (Source: 1989 Plastic Recycling Directory, Society of Plastics Industry.)

    2. The majority of paper comes from tree pulp, so naturally the impact in the form of deforestation is enormous. In 1999, 14 million trees were cut to produce the 10 billion paper grocery bags used by Americans that year alone.

      In fact, paper bag production delivers a detrimental double-whammy as forests (major absorbers of greenhouse gases) are cut down, combined with the actual manufacturing process of the bags, which produces toxic greenhouse gases, acid rain, and water pollution.

    3. Although paper bags have a higher recycling rate than plastic, only 10 to 15 percent of paper bags are recycled. And, making matters even less attractive, it takes 91 percent LESS energy to recycle a pound of plastic than it takes to recycle a pound of paper.

    4. Last but not least, current research indicates that paper does not degrade at a substantially faster rate than plastic once it’s in a landfill. You can still find readable newspapers from the 1930s in landfills… This is because virtually nothing degrades completely in modern landfills due to lack of water, light, oxygen and other factors necessary for successful degradation.

Don’t Just Ask For Change -- Be It

Simple lifestyle changes can do wonders for your health and the environment, and using reusable bags instead of plastic or paper bags is among the absolute easiest. Remember, each reusable shopping bag you use has the potential to eliminate hundreds, if not thousands, of plastic bags over its lifetime. This is clearly one area where you can have a dramatic impact if you encourage your friends, family and neighbors to follow your lead.

Get Your FREE Stylish Mercola.com Grocery Bags

To help you get started, I will be giving away one reusable bag with every order over $25 for the next week.


[+] Sources and References

Thank you! Your purchases help us support these charities and organizations.

Food Democracy Now
Mercury Free Dentistry
Fluoride Action Network
National Vaccine Information Center
Institute for Responsible Technology
Organic Consumers Association
Center for Nutrtion Advocacy
Cornucopia Institute
Vitamin D Council
GrassrootsHealth - Vitamin D*action
Alliance for Natural Health USA
American Holistic Veterinary Medical Foundation
The Rabies Challenge Fund
Cropped Catis Mexico