By Barbara Loe Fisher
This summer, inaccurate and misleading information about B. pertussis whooping cough and the pertussis vaccine is being put out there by medical doctors, who should know better.
Media campaigns designed to create fear about infectious disease are nothing new. This one appears to have three goals: first, to emphasize pertussis risks while ignoring vaccine risks; second, to place blame for whooping cough cases and deaths on the unvaccinated; and, third, to attack religious and conscientious belief exemptions, which serve as informed consent protections in U.S. vaccine laws.
Tools of the Trade: Fear, Intimidation, and 'Soft' Facts
In 2009, public health officials declared a pandemic H1N1 influenza emergency and played up the potential complications of the swine flu while playing down the potential risks of the untested new swine flu vaccine. 1
When two-thirds of Americans "just said no" to swine flu shots, NBC's chief medical editor Dr. Nancy Snyderman ridiculed them and quipped "Just get the damn vaccine." 2
Now Snyderman has issued a similar standing order to "get vaccinated" but, this time, she is accusing parents of unvaccinated children for causing the deaths of six California infants, who have reportedly died from complications of B. pertussis whooping cough.
On July 28, 2010, Dr. Snyderman further alleged that "most people" with religious objections to vaccination are not telling the truth and that the "needs" of the "community as a whole" are "better than the individual" and "more important." 3
Ordinarily I would not take the time to address specific comments by a prominent doctor, who is careless with the facts when voicing an opinion. But as more doctors use the bully pulpit of the national media – unchallenged - to disseminate incorrect information, promote personal ideological views and advance political agendas, it becomes more important for informed Americans to speak up.
Are Unvaccinated Children Responsible for Whooping Cough Outbreak?
Responding to recent press releases and media reports, in which California health officials say the state is experiencing the worst whooping cough outbreak in 50 years with about 1,500 reported cases and six infants dying from B. pertussis, 4 on July 28 Dr. Snyderman offered the following explanation:
"I think that what we are seeing here is a tipping point in unvaccinated children because the hot pockets are in families where, frankly, parents have under-vaccinated or decided not to vaccinate their children." 5
A quick fact check reveals that both California health officials and Snyderman have not been entirely honest with the people.
The Centers for Disease Control's published morbidity and mortality report shows that in the past 12 months, between July 24, 2009 and July 24, 2010, there were a total of 809 "provisional" cases of whooping cough reported in California.6 In fact, in the entire United States of America for the week ending July 24, there were only 187 reported cases of whooping cough, with no cases occurring in California.
Even the New York Times Acknowledges Problems with Pertussis Vaccine
The New York Times also reported that:
"The rise in pertussis doesn't seem to be related to parents' refusing to have their children vaccinated for fear of potential side effects.
In California, pertussis rates are about the same in counties with high childhood vaccination rates and low ones. And the C.D.C. reports that pertussis immunization rates have been stable or increasing since 1992."
When disease incidence statistics publicized by state health departments do not match those published by federal health agencies, there is something wrong.
It is time for California health officials to fully disclose complete details of the 1,500 whooping cough cases they allege have occurred in the state during the past year, including how many cases were lab confirmed as B. pertussis; how many cases were classified as "epidemiologically linked" - which means they were NOT lab confirmed; and the ages and vaccination status of all cases, including whether people with suspected or confirmed cases had been given 1,2,3,4,5,6 or more pertussis shots.
Pertussis Vaccine Does NOT Equal Lifelong Immunity
Most doctors know perfectly well that getting 3 to 6 doses of pertussis vaccine or more does not give lifelong immunity to whooping cough, and that other viruses and bacteria, such as parapertussis and RSV - which are not covered by the vaccine - can be misdiagnosed as pertussis if proper lab tests are not done. 7 , 8
In addition, public health officials know that B. pertussis bacteria have been evolving and become vaccine resistant, making the pertussis vaccine much less effective. 9
So Snyderman is engaging in pure speculation when she blames whooping cough-related deaths on the unvaccinated.
The truth is that infants can be as easily exposed to B. pertussis by coming into contact with a fully vaccinated infected person as with an unvaccinated person. 10
Dr. Snyderman goes on state that, "These are 6 infants who have lost their lives who, frankly, should not have died."
I agree. It is tragic when babies die from whooping cough and it is tragic when babies get pertussis containing vaccines and suffer convulsions, collapse/shock, high pitched screaming and other signs of brain inflammation and then, die.11
It is a tragedy when any baby dies, regardless of the cause.
The Polio Story
No fear campaign about infectious disease would be complete without bringing up polio. Snyderman says, "We were given our polio vaccine and the idea was that, if you get a vaccination, you will not get ill and you will not die."
Yes, that was the "idea" but it is not a fact.
Every vaccine carries a risk of injury and death that can be greater for some than others. There is no guarantee the vaccine will prevent an infectious disease and, depending upon the vaccine, it could actually give you the vaccine strain of the disease it is supposed to prevent.
In 1999, the U.S. abandoned use of the live virus oral polio vaccine to prevent individuals in America from being paralyzed by vaccine strain polio. 12
A lot of people don't know that if you swallow the live virus polio vaccine you can get paralyzed and die.
On top of that, recently vaccinated persons shed live poliovirus in their body fluids for weeks. People who come in close contact with them can get vaccine strain polio and be paralyzed or die.
Today, a killed polio vaccine is used in America because parents of vaccine injured children lobbied in the 1990's to get the polio vaccine policy changed.
But Dr. Snyderman only tells one side of the polio story, charging that: "Now people, frankly, have amnesia from the event. They forget what it was like to see people with these communicable diseases."
There are plenty of Americans, like me, who remember lining up for polio shots in the 1950's and 60's and were informed 40 years later, in the 1990's, that a lot of those experimental polio shots were contaminated with a monkey virus, simian virus 40, that causes cancer in lab animals and has been associated with brain, bone and lung cancers in children and adults. 13 , 14
We do remember polio and the iron lung. But we also remember not being told the whole truth about polio vaccine risks.
Then Snyderman takes out the big club and warns:
"I worry that, if we are under-vaccinating our children are you start to see things like whooping cough coming back, this is the canary in the coal mine. Last year we saw children die of measles and I worry that, if we see whooping cough and measles, that polio can't be far away."
Let's take another look at official federal disease incidence statistics to see whether that "worry" is justified or is just a lot of hype.
In 2009, out of 300 million people living in the United States, there were 71 cases of measles reported. This year, there have been 32 cases of measles. That's right: 32. There have been no cases of polio reported in America this year and only 1 case since 2006.15
Get a grip, Dr. Snyderman.
"In a country like this, where vaccinations are available, these communicable and infectious and deadly diseases shouldn't even be talked about," says Snyderman.
Most doctors know that vaccines only give temporary immunity at best and that microbes, like B. pertussis, are constantly evolving to survive. 16 , 17 That's why five or more doses of pertussis vaccine still can't prevent all whooping cough disease.
The One-Size-Fits-All Approach to Vaccines is Not in Your Child's Best Interest
We will likely be talking about whooping cough, measles, mumps, chicken pox and lots of other infectious diseases for a long, long time in this country and in every country, whether we get vaccinated or not.
"You know I have been an unabashed, unapologetic advocate for vaccinations. They are safe. They work," says Snyderman.
Many American doctors are "unapologetic" mandatory vaccination advocates because that is what they are told to be by public health officials and leaders in major medical organizations, such as the American Academy of Pediatrics18 and the American Medical Association.19 In fact, about 40 percent of pediatricians in America today proudly say they flatly deny medical care to families, who refuse to follow their orders to "get vaccinated."20
As important, though, is the question: How many of these doctors refuse to speak to, associate with, and condemn other doctors, who do treat patients making selective vaccine choices?
The truth is, vaccines are not safe for everyone and they do not work for everyone.
When doctors only tell half the truth about vaccine benefits and risks, people can sense it. And when they demean and threaten patients who ask questions or disagree with them, the fragile bond of trust between doctors and patients is broken.
Like when Dr. Snyderman demeans Americans, who exercise religious exemption to vaccination, an exemption which exists in all but two states.
"A lot of people are opting out on them [vaccines] and saying, "Well, it's against my religion" and I would say, for most people, that is just not true," she says.
It is annoying when anyone pretends to know another person's mind, heart and soul. But it is frightening when doctors believe they are entitled to judge the sincerity of another person's religious or conscientiously held beliefs.
With this comment, Dr. Snyderman has assumed the position of an Inquisitor. There is some comfort in knowing that the rack is no longer in fashion and the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution 21 has not yet been repealed.
The Risks of Pertussis-Containing Vaccines
"Make sure your children are vaccinated," says Snyderman.
This simplistic, one-size-fits-all approach to vaccination is dangerous.
Because there are children, who are at higher risk for becoming brain injured or dying after getting pertussis containing vaccines (DTaP, Tdap), including those who have suffered previous vaccine reactions like:22 ,23
- Very high fever
- High pitched screaming or persistent crying
- Convulsions (with or without fever)
- Collapse/shock (also known as hypo-tonic/hypo-responsive episodes)
- Brain Inflammation and encephalopathy
For a full list of precautions for children, teenagers and adults, read the manufacturer product inserts and get more information about how to recognize a vaccine reaction at www.NVIC.org.
Find out whether the pertussis vaccine your doctor is recommending for your child has been studied for safety and effectiveness when given at the same time as other vaccines.
For example, many pertussis vaccines have not been studied in clinical trials when a flu shot is given at the same time.
"If you are an adult and you are around a child under the age of one, get vaccinated," says Snyderman.
Again, it is important to know whether you, as an adult, are at high risk for suffering a pertussis vaccine reaction, such as being sick at the time of vaccination.
Pertussis Vaccine During Pregnancy
"If you are a woman of childbearing years, get vaccinated," says Snyderman.
How many pregnant women, whose doctors urge them to get a booster shot (Tdap), know that the vaccine has not been thoroughly studied in pregnant women?
Or that manufacturer product inserts include this disclaimer: 24
Animal reproduction studies have not been conducted…..It is not known whether [the vaccine] can cause fetal harm when administered to a pregnant woman, or can affect reproductive capacity. [The vaccine] has not been evaluated for carcinogenic or mutagenic potential, or for impairment of fertility.
But wait - Dr. Snyderman even tries to make us believe that unvaccinated people can infect immune compromised people simply by walking past them in the grocery store!
No, really. She says:
"And if you think, well, you can opt out [of vaccination], remember that, when you go to the grocery store and you walk by someone who has cancer or MS or any other compromised immune system, you put that person in harms way, too."
That an unvaccinated person can transmit infectious disease without hand shaking or kissing or coughing or sneezing - just a simple walk-by will do? 27
Nuremberg Code Revisited
And, finally, Dr. Snyderman gets to the heart the matter and promotes her personal ideological belief, which requires devaluing the individual:
"There is a time, when the community as a whole, their needs are better than the individual and, I think, more important," says Snyderman.
The judges at Nuremberg exposed what happened when doctors used the utilitarian rationale to conduct scientific research during World War II that forced individuals to risk their lives in drug, vaccine and other medical experiments. 30
The Nuremberg Code, which defined the ethical principle of informed consent, has served as the foundation for the ethical practice of medicine for more than half a century.
The informed consent principle makes it clear that the rights of the individual cannot, ethically, be sacrificed to the needs or interests of society. 31
But Dr. Snyderman goes further and marginalizes and condemns individuals, who do not agree with her utilitarian view.
"Right now, individuals are trumping the general populace at large and I find that, frankly, offensive and amoral," says Snyderman.
It is disturbing when prominent doctors tell half-truths and promote fear, hate and prejudice. We want to believe the doctors we trust with our health and our children's lives care about us as individuals.
Most people consider it is offensive and amoral to write off a minority of individuals as expendable in service to the rest. Because then, the question becomes: How many individuals can be sacrificed for what some in positions of authority have defined as "the greater good?"
Is it 300? 3,000? 30,000?
Or can we go as high as three million?
That is only 1 percent of 300 million Americans, after all.
How Many Vaccine-Injured Victims are There?
The truth is, nobody knows how many vaccine victims there are in America, how many of the 1 in 6 learning disabled children; or the 1 in 9 with asthma; or the 1 in 100 who develop autism; or the 1 in 450 who become diabetic, can trace their chronic inflammation, disease and disability back to vaccine reactions that have been dismissed by public health officials and doctors for the past century as just "a coincidence." 32 , 33
When parents of vaccine injured children held the first public demonstration in front of the CDC in Atlanta on May 12, 1986, the larger question we asked public health officials was "Do you know how many?"
After we marched, we made presentations to the CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, (ACIP) and asked the Committee questions and, then,
I gave a report on my investigation into whooping cough outbreaks in 1985, which had been heavily publicized by physician officials at the American Academy of Pediatrics.
I found that many of the whooping cough cases reported in eight states in 1985 had not been lab confirmed and the majority had occurred in vaccinated children and adults. (You can read a transcript of what happened at that May 1986 CDC meeting on NVIC's website.) 34
Nothing much has changed in the last 25 years.
Whooping cough is still infecting both vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals.
There are pertussis increases every four to five years, no matter how high the vaccination rate.35
Many children and adults survive whooping cough disease without complications but some do not. And some doctors in positions of power are still in the business of creating fear and demonizing those, who make informed health choices that do not include use of 16 government recommended vaccines. 36 , 37 ,38
Get Educated – Make Informed Decisions
Dr. Snyderman concludes her diatribe by focusing on her own fears, while wistfully clinging to the myth that vaccines will eradicate all infectious diseases in America - if only every man, woman and child would dutifully comply with doctors' orders to "get vaccinated."
"I think this winter, as whooping cough upticks, measles continues to be under-vaccinated, we're going to increasingly see pockets of communicable infections that a few decades ago we thought, frankly, we had eradicated from the United States. These illnesses should not be seen in the United States with the vaccinations that we have at hand," says Snyderman.
And when asked if she believes pertussis will spread beyond the borders of California into other states, she compared it to the spreading outbreaks of measles, stating that, "Last year in Minnesota and in Philadelphia we know children died of measles."
This despite the fact that there was not a single measles-related death in the US last year. According to the CDC information site on measles, there were a total of 71 reported cases of measles in 2009. No deaths.
Abe Lincoln once said "You can fool some of the people all of the time and all of the people some of the time, but you can't fool all the people all of the time."
How long is it going to take for medical doctors, who have abandoned their critical thinking skills and lost themselves in orthodoxy, to stop fooling themselves so they can accurately inform their patients about the benefits and risks of vaccination 39 40 and respect the choices their patients make? 41 42
Whatever doctors decide to do and whether they ever conduct the good scientific studies that will answer outstanding questions about vaccination, individuals should always have the freedom to exercise informed consent to medical risk-taking.
That freedom protects individuals and minorities from exploitation by those in positions of authority in society, who do not know what they do, as well as from those who do know what they are doing.
The freedom to make an informed, voluntary decision about what we are willing to risk our lives or our children's lives for is not just an individual need, it is a human right. It is a human right and a freedom worth defending in this and every century.
- 1 National Vaccine Information Center. Pandemic H1N1 Swine Flu: What About You & Your Family?
- 2 MSNBC-TV. "Morning Meeting." August 25, 2009.
- 3 NBC-TV. "The Today Show." July 28, 2010. Meredith Vieira & Nancy Snydernan, M.D.
- 4 California Department of Public Health. Press Release: CDPH Broadens Recommendations for Vaccinating Against Pertussis: Immunization Key to Controlling Whooping Cough. July 19, 2010.
- 5 Transcript of Meredith Vieira interview of Nancy Snyderman, M.D. on NBC-TV "The Today Show." July 28, 2010.
- 6 CDC. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR). Vol. 59, No. 29. July 30, 2010.
- 7 He Q, Vijanen MK et al. Whooping Cough Caused by Bordetella pertussis and Bordetella parapertussis in an Immunized Population. JAMA. 1998; 280: 635-637.
- 8 Liese JG, Renner C. Clinical and epidemiological picture of B pertussis and B parapertussis infections after introduction of acellular pertussis vaccines. Archives of Diseases in Childhood 2003; 88: 684-687.
- 9 Preston A. Bordetella pertussis: the intersection of genomics and pathobiology. Canadian Medical Association Journal. July 5, 2005. 173 (1)
- 10 Mooi F R, van LooI HM, King A. Adaptation of Bordetella pertussis to Vaccination: A Cause for its Reemergence? Emerging Infectious Diseases. Vol. 7, No. 3 Supplement June 2001.
- 11 HRSA. National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP). Claims Filed and Compensated or Dismissed by Vaccine. (up to May 5, 2010). and Statistics Report: Awards Paid (as of June 7, 2010).
- 12 Alexander LN, Seward JF et al. Vaccine Policy Changes and Epidemiology of Poliomyelitis in the United States. JAMA. 2004; 298:1696-1701.
- 13 Carlsen W. Rogue Virus in the Vaccine: Early Polio Vaccine Harbored Virus Now Feared to Cause Cancer in Humans. San Francisco Chronicle. July 15, 2001.
- 14 Fisher BL. Congressional Testimony: The SV-40 Virus: Has Tainted Polio Vaccine Caused an Increase in Cancer? U.S. House Government Reform Committee. September 10, 2003.
- 15 MMWR. See Reference #6.
- 16 Diavatopoulos DA, Cummings CA et al. Bordetella pertussis, the Causative Agent of Whooping Cough, Evolved from a Distinct Human-Associated Lineage of B. bronchiseptica. PLOS Pathogens. December 2005: Vol. 1, Issue 4.
- 17 McIntosh M. Bacteria Take Short Cuts to Evolve on Fast Track. UA News (University of Arizona). May 10, 2001.
- 18 Diekema DS. Responding to Parental Refusals of Immunization of Children. Pediatrics. Vol. 115, No. 5. May 2005; pp: 1428-1431. (Reaffirmed as AAP Policy on May 1, 2009).
- 19 Medical News Today. AACAP Applauds AMA's Support for Universal Vaccinations. June 19, 2009.
- 20 Flanagan-Klygis EA, Sharp L, Frader JE. Dismissing the Family Who Refuses Vaccines. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2005; 159:929-934.
- 21 U.S. Constitution – First Amendment.
- 22 National Vaccine Information Center. Pertussis (Whooping Cough) and Pertussis Vaccine.
- 23 Sanofi-Pasteur. DAPTACEL Product Insert. March 2008.
- 24 GlaxoSmithKline. Boosterix Product Insert. December 2008.
- 25 Siegel JD, Rhinehart E et al. 2007 Guidelines for Isolation Precautions: Preventing Transmission of Infectious Agents in Healthcare Settings. CDC.
- 26 Andre JB, Gupta S. Frank S, Tibayrenc M. Evolution and immunology of infectious diseases: What's new? An E-debate. Infection, Genetics and Evolution (2004) 69-75.
- 27 Oklahoma Department of Public Health. Public Health Fact Sheet: Preventing Infectious Diseases Daily With Healthy Behavior. November 2007.
- 28 Mautner, T. Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832). The Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy. and Utilitarianism. The Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy.
- 29 Ross KL. The Mummy's Curse: Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832).
- 30 Seidelman WE. Nuremberg lamentation: for the forgotten victims of medical science. BMJ 1996; 313:1463-7.
- 31 Katz J. The Consent Principle of the Nuremberg Code: It's Significance Then and Now. The Nazi Doctors and the Nuremberg Code (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992), pp. 227-239.
- 32 Coulter HL, Fisher BL. DPT: A Shot in the Dark (San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1985).
- 33 Fisher BL. Vaccines, Autism & Chronic Inflammation: The New Epidemic. 2008.
- 34 Transcript (partial). May 12, 1986 Meeting of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). Transcribed in 1986 from audio tapes.
- 35 MSNBC. Health Today: Growing outbreaks of whooping cough raise health fears. July 28, 2010.
- 36 Cox L, Walker E. Doctors May 'Fire" Parents Who Don't Vaccinate Children. ABC News. October 23, 2009.
- 37 Nguyen P. Parents who don't vaccinate their kids put us all at risk. UCLA Today. June 1, 2010.
- 38 PBS. Frontline: The Vaccine War. April 27, 2010.
- 39 Legido A, Tenembaum SN, Katsetos CD, Menkes JH. Autoimmune & Postinfectious Diseases (Chapter 8). Child Neurology – 7th Edition. Lippencott Williams & Wilkins, 2006. Pages 631-634 (Neurologic Complications of Immunizations).
- 40 Fisher BL. Whooping Cough Outbreaks & Vaccine Failures. NVIC. July 7, 2010. http://www.nvic.org/NVIC-Vaccine-News/July-2010/Whooping-Cough-Outbreaks-Vaccine-Failures.aspx
- 41 NBC "The Today Show." March 1997. Matt Lauer, Barbara Loe Fisher, Neal Halsey, M.D.
- 42 Fisher BL. National Vaccine Advisory Committee. The Moral Right to Religious, Conscientious or Personal Belief Exemption to Mandatory Vaccination Laws. May 2, 1997.