By
Linda Carlton
To understand autism we can begin this journey from what we have
learned about how seemingly insignificant dietary changes can affect
newborn primates. In October 1975, three Japanese scientists raised
a group of infant primates. By artificial nursing, these primates
were fed a casein powdered milk formula. When they modified the
infant formula to reduce the content of protein and increased the
lactose to supplement the appropriate number of calories, the primate
infants developed abnormal behaviors such as stereotype rocking,
fear, aggression, head banging and other autistic-like behaviors.
Completely unaware of what they had discovered, the scientists had
induced autism in a clinical setting.
Now, they were aware that by reducing the protein content they
caused the infants to become malnourished. They also observed that
without human contact some infants were much more impaired. They
learned that the infants that received the standard solution were
reared successfully. At that time they concluded that a protein
deficiency had caused a decline in physical and mental growth. Subsequent
studies have supported this, whereby protein deficiency does cause
developmental delay.
Autism Versus Developmental Delay
But it is important to know which symptoms are truly autistic and
which are that of developmental delay. These disorders are often
used interchangeably, but they are very different. For example,
hand flapping is an autistic symptom, but it is not a common characteristic
of developmental delay. In developmental delay children are often
slow to learn, and will quickly fall behind their peers. The symptoms
of these primates were more than just symptoms of developmental
delay--they were symptoms of autism.
The most important information we have about these infant primates
is that the researchers had also increased the lactose content in
their diet. If the quantity of protein matched that of the quantity
of lactose, this might not have occurred, or it might also have
occurred if they had been fed too much protein. The standard formula
given to the infant primates that were reared successfully were
given the same amount of lactose, and what would have been the normal
amount of protein for these size mammals.
Lactose and Autism
Lactose is the key to unraveling what happened to these infants.
Bacteria use lactose, or milk sugar, as a nutrient base. Bifidobacteria
and clostridia use lactose, and they often describe these strains
of bacteria as lactose-fermenting bacteria. One difference in Bifidobacteria
and Clostridia is that only one can produce significant amounts
of ammonia, only one can damage the intestines. Milk oligosaccharides
contain lactose; they are fermented in the infant colon where they
selectively stimulate the growth of Bifidobacteria. Clostridia are
competitors of Bifidobacteria, and Clostridia produce ammonia. Ammonia
and only ammonia produced from bacteria could have caused the aberrant
behaviors.
The infant primates had developed symptoms of autism because there
was protein restriction, milk proteins needed for ammonia detoxification,
and not necessarily just casein. They were fed lactose and lactose
ferments ammonia, producing bacteria. They were unable to detoxify
on a protein-deficient diet. It is a simple formula:
Protein + Lactose = Normal Development
Low protein + High Lactose = Autism
But protein malnutrition does not equal autism nor does lactose
feeding equal autism. However,
Protein malnutrition + high-lactose feeding + (the unknown factor)
= Autism
There has to be an unknown factor for this to occur, a combination
of things that all relate to one another. The unknown factor can
be found by testing these three variables. We have to review other
information that we have on children with autism to give us the
correct answer to the unknown factor.
A low-protein diet offsets a nitrogen balance to detoxify ammonia,
whereas lactose feeding ferments bacteria. The only variable that
could account for the unknown factor is ammonia. In autism, there
are signs of ammonia detoxification, for example when GABA and nitric
oxide are increased. So instead of developing overt ammonia toxicity,
they are able to detoxify this excess ammonia. As encouraging as
this sounds it still depletes cellular energy. Many parents can
recall 'staring spells' as the first behavioral change in a child
prior to autistic regression. This can be the first sign of increased
blood ammonia.
Other symptoms found in children with only minimal increases in
blood ammonia were:
- Developmental regression
- Loss of acquired speech
- Stereotype hand movements
- Myoclonic seizures
- Generalized epileptic discharges
- Repetitive behaviors
- Sensory dysfunction
- Auditory and visual hallucinations
Finegold and his colleagues have published three studies on children
with autism. The first study was with the use of antibiotics. The
second study of stool specimens indicated a vast overpopulation
of Clostridia in children with autism. Many physicians use antibiotics
for treatment of elevated blood ammonia to kill the ammonia-producing
bacteria. Antibiotics have produced dramatic effects in children
with autism, however this treatment did inevitably fail. Experiments
with fermented foods after antibiotic treatments have been somewhat
successful in preventing relapsing Clostridial infections.
Live Bacteria to Temper Immune Response
As many of us already know, treatment with probiotic supplements
at most show only minor, if any, improvement in autistic symptoms.
These can sometimes take weeks or even months to take affect or
may never have any effect. The reason for this is that when probiotic
bacteria are dried and then rehydrated, even with prebiotic assistance
it takes time for these bacteria to reestablish a colony. When live
bacteria are frozen they can re-colonize within 24 hours at room
temperature, but when bacteria are heat-killed they induce an immune
response and their ability to re-colonize is remote. Each time we
consume foods with heat-killed bacteria it produces an immune response.
Every time we receive a vaccination with heat-killed bacteria or
a heat-killed virus, it produces a similar immune response. Live
bacteria such as that of lactic acid bacteria can temper these immune
responses. The infant primates were fed heat-treated formulas, Clostridia
is an opportunist infection, looking for a chance to colonize. However,
Clostridia is also a natural inhabitant of the colon. The problem
here with heat-treated foods is that you might as well say they
are sterile. If you are feeding sterile foods, they don't contain
bacteria that can form
a colony. So in order to colonize bacteria you have to consume foods
with live bacteria or an opportunist will take that invitation.
Breast-fed babies are colonized naturally by Bifidobacteria. Babies
fed formula develop much more harmful fecal environments. Preterm
infants are especially at risk for Clostridrial infections because
there is usually a delay in breast feeding. In older children generally
pathogenic Clostridial infections develop after antibiotic treatment,
which can destroy the beneficial bacteria derived from the mother.
Impaired Digestion and Pasteurized Milk
Pasteurized milk causes the impaired digestion of casein and other
proteins found in milk. Malnutrition is caused by either an insufficient
diet or an impaired utilization of foods. Malabsorption is the impairment
of intestinal absorption of nutrients. Some children with protein-calorie
deficiency had abnormal intestinal fat absorption, and because of
this they had an increased uptake of serotonin in the plasma. One
scientific study found hyperserotoninaemia in 70 percent of their
autistic patients. It should come as no surprise that serotonin
uptake inhibitors have had some success in treating autistic children.
The medical literature supports the realization that protein deficiency
causes developmental delay and even mild increases in ammonia causes
oddities in behavior.
Some methods of ammonia detoxification have been suggested with
the use of lactulose, oral lactulose and the drug Tributyrate, which
can scavenge excess ammonia. Lactulose can cause extreme irritability
in children, and perhaps its use with autistic children was abandoned
due to these circumstances.
Impacted Colons and Pasteurized Milk
Children with autism frequently have impacted colons. Clostridia
is notorious for reducing the quantity of water in the colon. Hard
dry stools can cause irritability once stool-softening products
are started. These stools might only be removed by using an enema
prior to beginning any stool-softening treatment. Once the bowels
have been cleared of extremely hard, dry stools, then treatment
with stool softeners can begin.
What we have to consider is the matter of colonizing bacteria.
A healthy colon in a normal infant contains a significant supply
of Bifidobacteira. Pasteurized milk simply putrefies in the colon
and hinders the passage of fecal matter. Pasteurized
milk contains heat-killed bacteria and is unable to reflourish
the colon with host-friendly bacteria--unless contaminated, it is
sterile.
When milk proteins are damaged by heat processing it renders them
indigestible. Raw milk does
not cause constipation. Constipation is caused by the loss of moisture.
Lactose and lactulose add moisture back to the colon, but clostridia
can quickly dry up the feces. Raw milk is easily digestible by infants,
for as long as babies have been born mothers have been feeding their
young casein and other milk proteins. Clostridia can feed on unabsorbed
lactose from the diet. Lactose is completely hydrolyzed in cheeses
made with bifidobacteria.
Autism and Casein-Free Diets
Science cannot support the presumption that a casein-free diet
reduces autistic symptoms. All the literature on casein restriction
indicates this only causes a developmental delay. If an improvement
is seen on a casein-free diet, it is only because of the removal
of free lactose, and the removal of constipating foods.
The very worst thing that you can do to a child coping with mercury
is to wean them off of breast or raw milk. Weaning causes the hair
and blood mercury levels to suddenly drop, and it is re-routed to
the colon for excretion. If the child is constipated, it could mean
real problems.
Now we know three Japanese researchers were able to induce autism
in a clinical setting, with a low-protein, high-lactose, sterilized
formula. The belief that infant-mother separation or the refrigerator
mother causes autistic symptoms continued for many years. Understanding
what happened to these infant primates could have changed the course
of medical history. Unfortunately, two new theories of what causes
autistic symptoms have followed.
Treating Autistic Symptoms
To treat the symptoms of autism, we have to feed our children foods
that they can digest, foods that do not cause constipation, foods
that will give them back the bacterial environment to temper these
inflammatory conditions. And most importantly return to proper nitrogen-ammonia
balance.
Treatment should begin with a healthy diet, high in quality protein
foods such as eggs, meat, milk and cheese and balanced essential
oils. Raw goat's or raw cow's milk may be given. If not well tolerated,
then cultured raw milk/kefir can
be used. Oral, inexpensive butyrate may be given to both clean the
colon and to detoxify ammonia from the liver and bowels.
To finalize, there are still the issues of treating malabsorption,
the impairment of intestinal absorption of nutrients and abnormal
intestinal fat absorption. To begin nutritional rehabilitation for
your child you will need some help navigating through the complicated
process. Dr. Patricia Kane has treated thousands of children with
autism over the past 25 years who have not only had malnutrition,
but also abnormal intestinal fat absorption. Restoration of digestive
function is critical to absorbing dietary essential fatty acids
and stabilizing the nutrient base.
Japanese scientists in 1975 documented the development of autistic
symptoms and revealed how diet can induce these symptoms. In 2004
we now have the tools to eradicate the symptoms of autism.