SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
Can Grilling Meat Cause Cancer?

grill, barbecueThe American Institute of Cancer Research is urging everyone to rethink the pastime of barbecuing meat.

After analyzing the results of 7,000 studies, the Institute concluded that grilling any meat -- whether red, white or fish -- produces potent carcinogens.

The high heat of grilling reacts with proteins in red meat, poultry and fish, creating heterocyclic amines, which are linked to cancer. Another form of cancer-causing agents, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, are created when juices from meats drip and hit the heat source. They then rise in smoke and can stick to the meat.

The Institute took particular aim at processed meats like hot dogs, sausages, bacon, ham, pastrami, salami and any meat that has been salted, smoked or cured. The chemicals used to preserve the meat increase the production of cancer-causing compounds, regardless of how the meat is cooked.

The Institute’s report said it “could find no amount of processed meat that is safe to eat.”

Sources:

Dr. Mercola''s Comments Dr. Mercola's Comments:

I know the thought of giving up your barbecue grill is about as un-American as you can get, especially right as summer is approaching, but I do believe it is a wise move for your health.
But it’s not just the grill that’s the problem. Any time you cook meat at high temperatures, whether you’re grilling, frying, broiling, etc., some pretty nasty chemicals are created:
  • Heterocyclic Amines (HCAs): These form when food is cooked at high temperatures, and they’re linked to cancer. In terms of HCA, the worst part of the meat is the blackened section, which is why you should always avoid charring your meat, and never eat blackened sections.
  • Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs): When fat drips onto the heat source, causing excess smoke, and the smoke surrounds your food, it can transfer cancer-causing PAHs to the meat.
  • Advanced Glycation End Products (AGEs): When food is cooked at high temperatures (including when it is pasteurized or sterilized), it increases the formation of AGEs in your food. When you eat the food, it transfers the AGEs into your body. AGEs build up in your body over time leading to oxidative stress, inflammation and an increased risk of heart disease, diabetes and kidney disease.
It’s ironic, isn’t it, that so many people are convinced they must cook their foods until they’re browned and “well-done” to avoid bacteria, when in so doing they are creating and consuming highly toxic substances that will shorten their lifespan?

There are many people who are convinced that being a vegetarian is the ultimate healthy lifestyle eating plan. They support their position with loads of scientific studies. But it is my belief that most of these studies are correct because the common way most people consume animal protein is COOKED, or worse yet grilled, creating all the toxic substances discussed above.

To the best of my knowledge there are no studies comparing raw animal-food-based diets versus cooked vegetarian diets, but even if there were they still could be flawed because they most likely would not factor in the person’s nutritional type.

Remember a carb nutritional type eating large amounts of raw animal food will do just as poorly as a protein type on raw vegan diet. You simply need the right food for your specific nutritional type.

Personally, I just moved into a new home that is designed for entertaining large amounts of people and I have yet to install a grill. I am really torn because I fully appreciate the damage grilling does to the food. It is very hard for me to consciously serve that food to guests, so I am still personally debating this.

One variable that makes me consider it is that you simply don’t have to be perfect in your diet. I fully believe you just need to eat very well 80-95% of the time. If you do that your body typically has enough reserve to compensate for the damage you cause. However if you are really sick or have a terminal illness you will want to get as close to 100% as practically possible to improve your chances of recovery.

Do You STILL Want to Over-Cook Your Food?

If so, consider the following, quite sobering, statistics:

1. In one study, researchers found that those who ate their beef medium-well or well-done had more than three times the risk of stomach cancer as those who ate their beef rare or medium-rare.

2. Other studies have shown that an increased risk of developing pancreatic, colorectal, and breast cancer is associated with high intakes of well-done, fried, or barbecued meats.

3. One study found that a compound called PhIP, formed when meat is charred at high temperatures, causes prostate cancer in rats.

4. Scientists have estimated that the average cancer risk because of heterocyclic amine exposure ranges from 1 per 10,000 for the average person to more than 1 per 50 for those ingesting large amounts of well-done muscle meats, especially flame-grilled chicken.

I could go on, but I think you get the point.

Yet, I realize that asking most Americans to give up hot dogs, hamburgers, barbequed chicken and even grilled fish is almost sacrilegious. So let me try to put it another way.

What is Your Food Doing for You?

Depending on the food, and how it is prepared, it can either nourish your body and vitalize your mind, or it can slowly degenerate your vitality and vigor.

The choice is yours.

And instead of thinking about what you are giving up by avoiding overcooked foods, think about what you are gaining: light energy in the form of biophotons.

You may already be aware of the importance of getting sunlight on your skin. Well, you can absorb sun energy via your food as well, and stored sun energy in food is called 'biophotons,' which are the smallest physical units of light.

The more light a food is able to store, the more nutritious it is. This is why sun-ripened veggies, and even meat products from animals raised outside in the sun, are rich in biophotons.

Biophotons, meanwhile, contain bio-information, which controls complex vital processes in your body. The biophotons have the power to elevate your physical body to a higher oscillation or order, and this is manifested as a feeling of vitality and well-being.

But as soon as you throw those sun-ripened peppers or raw, grass-fed steak onto the grill, you lose these beneficial properties, as cooked foods contain no biophotons.

All Meat is NOT Inherently Bad for You

As usual, those of you who have commented in the Community Comments section below have made some very good points, including the glaring errors in studies like the one above.

If you take it at face value, you are left with the incorrect notion that meat is something you should only eat sparingly, if at all. Yet there are numerous factors that influence the quality or health-value of the meat you eat, even above and beyond how it’s cooked. That includes:
  • Whether or not it’s organic (conventional meat is loaded with pesticides, hormones, antibiotics and other chemicals)
  • Whether or not it’s grass-fed (essential for healthy meat)
  • Whether or not it contains nitrates, preservatives linked to cancer
What it did point out is that processed meats are a big-time no-no, and I have to agree with them there. While you can find natural and organic processed meats, the unprocessed varieties are still preferable.

The other factor that plays a role in how healthy meat is for you?

As I said earlier, your nutritional type. Some of you (including myself) thrive on red meat while others need white meats or mostly other protein sources, like eggs. It all depends on your unique biochemistry.

For Those of You Who Won’t Have Summer Without Your Grill

I suspect this may be a great number of you, so I will include some tips to minimize your risk.

1. Limit the amount of grilled foods you eat, and make sure you’re eating plenty of other raw foods in your diet.

2. You can reduce the amount of PAHs when you grill by not cooking fatty meats, and by trimming the fat off before you grill.

3. When grilling, cook your food with indirect heat, such as on a rack rather than directly on the coals. Cooking on a cedar plank is also helpful.

4. Always avoid charring your meat (and don't eat the black or brown parts).

5. Cook meat partially before putting it on the grill, or cook smaller pieces of meat, which take less time to cook, and therefore give HCAs less time to form.

6. You can reduce the amount of AGEs in your food by using an acidic marinade that contains lemon juice or vinegar.

7. Marinating meats before grilling or broiling them can reduce HCAs (according to some experts by 90 percent or more). However, only use natural ingredients for marinades, and keep the coating thin to avoid charring.

8. Flip your burgers often, as this will help cut down on HCAs.

9. Add blueberries or cherries to your burgers, as they can also help prevent the formation of HCAs.

10. Avoid grilling hot dogs, bratwurst and other processed meats, as these seem to be among the worst offenders.

11. Only grill high-quality, organic and grass-fed meats.

12. Cook the meat as little as possible. Rare or medium-rare at the absolute most. You can also quickly sear the meat on both sides, leaving the inside mostly raw. This gives the illusion that you’re eating cooked meat, with many of the benefits of raw.


Related Links:



Comment on This Article Community Comments (38)
 
 
Posted On Jun 04, 2008
"The institute took particular aim at processed meats like hot dogs, sausages, bacon, ham, pastrami, salami and any meat that has been salted, smoked or cured. The chemicals used to preserve meat increase the production of cancer-causing compounds."

There is a very clear bias against meat out there and like others who've already posted, I'm not falling for it. Using primarily processed meat as their foil, they find the negative information they're looking for and they then apply it against all other meat, usually red meat, no matter how slim the associations are at that point.

What they don't use is basic scientific method because it would show that meat is really fine. They don't seperate the nitrates. They don't consider the vast quantities of pesticides used in feed that accumulates in animal tissue, mainly fat, which tends to liquidize and drip causing the smoke they're talking about. Even fish isn't excluded because much of it is farmed (I wonder if they disclose whether they used farmed or wild fish), and even wild fish is tainted with heavy metals.

They also don't compare the degree of carcinogenic exposure to various other forms of carcinogenic exposure, such as simply living in northern lattitudes.

I'll tell you this folks: people have been grilling their meat from nearly the beginning; for Americans it's almost a way of life and for good reason: the result is one of the finest pleasures a human being can have. Life should be enjoyed. Risks cannot be entirely eliminated, but they can be mitigated to varying degrees. I'll sacrifice some things that are not important for my enjoyment of life, but my grill stays right where it is.

 
Swami Barmi
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 10/2006
Swami Barmi  
Replied

Sheila C
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 1/2007
Sheila C  
 
Posted On Jun 04, 2008
You are so right Swami.  You start off with an organic piece of meat, it doesn't matter how you cook it.  The worse thing about barbequing is the ungodly amounts of tin foil used.  Get rid of your aluminum foil!


LotusLifeSciences
Novice User Novice User Joined On 5/2008
LotusLifeSciences  
 
Posted On Jun 19, 2008

I am a student of Ayurvedic medicine. In my studies, I have learned some of the basic principles is understanding that we have a specific dosha or body chemistry. I mention this because Mercola and a few of you have mentioned this in your comments. After learning my dosha and eating more of the foods that help my health and removing the foods that cause disturbances, I am in a much better state of physical and mental health. Of course, I am Hindu so never ate much meat to begin with. There are lots of online tests to help you determine your dosha, check it out and see if it is helpful for you.


 
 
 
Posted On Jun 03, 2008
Grilling may have been the first method of cooking meat.  Considering this, maybe it is important to note that the article mentioned the worst foods to grill are the processed foods. It stands to reason, that the toxic chemicals from the food would combine make a toxic smoke when it drips, coating the food again.  Also, consider the source of grilling.  Are you using a gas grill?  Charcoal?  I think very few of us grill using a wood fire!  I think we should avoid making a conclusion without looking at the multiple factors involved.

 
curlilox
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 8/2007
curlilox  
Replied

bmc
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 2/2007
bmc  
 
Posted On Jun 03, 2008
Exactly. Did they try organic fresh meat that did not have any nitrates or anything added to it?

 
 
 
Posted On Jun 19, 2008

Is there no common sense left in this world?  If anyone now a days doesn't understand that anything industrially processed is harmful, for them there is little hope.  The oldest way of cooking meat was by burnt sacrifice and those people lived hundreds of years. When it's your time to go - it's your time to go.  Just think of those poor people walking down the sidewalk when a helecopter fell on them!  How much fear mongering can we take?Really.


 
T101
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 5/2008
T101  
 
 
 
Posted On Jun 19, 2008

there has never been raw hunter gather tribe, in fact they cooked most of there foods..

and the china is study is a joke, dont even bother reading that stuff..... traditional asians get most of there calories from pork fat and fish, followed by rice and vegetables.


 
freeseb
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 6/2006
freeseb  
 
 
 
Posted On Jun 02, 2008
Actually, according to the P450 table, grilling meat lowers estrogen levels, just like tobacco.

 
samurai
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 4/2007
samurai  
Replied

Robubba
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 3/2008
Robubba  
 
Posted On Jun 03, 2008
I actually thought tobacco would be moderately healthy if they weren't wrapped in God-knows-what


curlilox
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 8/2007
curlilox  
 
Posted On Jun 04, 2008
Since you're talking about tobacco, my friend's grandpa rolled his own cigarettes for years until they made him switch.  He never got sick from his own smokes.  It' wasn't until he started smoking the prepackaged cigarettes that he got sick from those.  I'm not advocating smoking or tobacco, but I KNOW they put more in cigarettes than tobacco!


Robubba
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 3/2008
Robubba  
 
Posted On Oct 06, 2008

cur, that's what I would expect. Because tobacco is simply a semifermented and dehydrated plant leaf. There is definitely more to cigs than what I would want to put in my body. Why don't we just lower taxes on pure tobacco. Industries would loose major business (unless they conformed) when everyone runs to the cheap stuff, and health wouldn't suffer as much.


 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.