FREE Subscription
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter   
 
 
POSTED BY
March 09 2005
1,495 Views

BROWSE BY CATEGORY

Can Vegan Diets Hurt Kids?

 
Vegan Diets

Parents who follow a strict vegan lifestyle and raise their children as strict vegans are putting their child's developmental health at risk according to a scientist with the U.S. Agricultural Research Service. The scientist also stated that living under the philosophy that "meat is murder" is an unethical practice as it results in children missing out on important nutrients found only in animal sources.

Stunted Development

Studies revealed that pregnant women who adhere to strict vegan diets give birth to children with developmental side effects such as small birth weight, slow growth and developmentally delayed. In some cases the effects are permanent.

To determine the importance of meat sources in the diet researchers conducted a study of over 500 African schoolchildren who were raised on diets that consisted primarily of starchy, low-nutrition corn and bean staples. The diets also lacked micronutrients such as vitamin B12, zinc and iron, which are commonly found in meat sources.

The study lasted for two years and the children were placed into four groups:

  • In the first group children were given 2-oz. supplements of meat a day. This amount was equivalent to approximately two spoonfuls of mince.

  • Two other groups received either a cup of milk a day or an oil supplement containing the same amount of energy.

  • The diet of a fourth group was left unaltered.

The results of the groups of children who were given the meat and to a lesser extent the milk or oil were significant. They showed higher performance scores on intelligence tests and problem-solving skills than any of the other children at the end of the study. It was also discovered that the addition of meat to the children's diets nearly eliminated previous high rates of vitamin B12 deficiency among the children.

Experts expressed that the results from the study was an effective indicator that adding animal food sources to diets was the much more feasible option to combating worldwide malnutrition than resorting to quick fix supplements.

Vegans Fight Back

The Chief Executive officer of the Vegan Society in the UK argued that a vegan diet provided energy and nutrition and considered plant sources for the most part a safer and cheaper source of nutrients. Her recommendation to vegan followers was to supplement their diets with vitamin B12.

BBC News February 21, 2005



Dr. Mercola Dr. Mercola's Comments:

Avoiding all animal protein (vegan diet) isn't healthy for many people and this study further drives this point home. If you know of someone or a family who are following a strict vegan or vegetarian lifestyle, please pass this article on to them as it just may spare them from an important deficiency--vitamin B12, which is essential to human life.

Many vegetarians, just like the CEO of the UK Vegan society in the article above, believe that B12 supplementation is all that is required to compensate for not eating meat. Unfortunately, vitamin B12 is not absorbed very well, if at all, from plant sources. Previous studies have consistently shown low B12 levels in vegetarians and vegans because they do not eat meat and other animal byproducts. There are ways to obtain adequate B12 from non-animal sources, but they are rarely utilized. However, that really misses the point, as I am confident that there are other micronutrients available in animal food that will cause deficiency syndromes.

About one-third of people are carb metabolic types, Carb types actually do quite well with very small amounts of protein and fat. However, they still require some animal proteins (not necessarily meat), such as small amounts of raw dairy, white chicken or turkey, fish or eggs. If they avoid these, or similar animal proteins, it is highly likely they will suffer some future health complication.

Conversely, just as we need some animal proteins, we all need vegetables. Carb types need up to 70 percent or more of their diet as vegetables. They typically do wonderfully well on a vegetarian diet. However, protein types need far less vegetables, but they still need vegetables to stay healthy.

Interestingly, many people decide to become a vegetarian or vegan for spiritual reasons. I don't recall anyone ever deciding to eat meat for spiritual reasons. The danger here is when you rely on your brain to dictate your behavior. It is far better to listen to the body that God gave you to determine exactly what foods to eat. God designed your body to provide you with all the feedback you need to make the best choices. If that means eating nearly all vegetables or very little vegetables it will become obvious to you once you pay attention to what your body is telling you.

Related Articles:

Can Eliminating Meat From Your Diet Lower Your Blood Pressure?

Is Being a Vegetarian Part of Living Healthy and Longer?

Dangers of a Vegetarian Diet in Teens

How a Vegetarian Resolved Underweight and Rosacea Problems

Do Vegetarian Diets Really Work?

Vegetarian Diet Healthy and Safe

Did you find this article interesting?  Interesting Not Useful
Community Comments ( 3 )
Comment on this Article
  
  
Amy777
[ Joined on 02/08 ] [ Posted on June 13, 2008 ]
1 Points        
   
 
Novice User

I have been primarily a vegan for the last 20 years and I have a son who is 9 - totally vegan. We are vegan because of the risk of disease in dead and decaying animals. In the last 20 years, I have improved my eyesight, gained bone density and feel 20, rather than the 40 I felt when I was 20 being on a diet rich in meats. My energy level is extremely good and I can out - endure many teenagers in my martial arts classes. My son checks out completely healthy by my doctor and has "astronaught" eyes. He is tall and very quick. When he was born his scores were 100 %!!! I guess our B-12 is just fine, and from plant sources! Anyone else have a good story? I have no doubt I will be rollerblading with my son when I am 90!!

 [ Reply ]
  
  
Jeff_Orr
[ Joined on 03/08 ] [ Posted on August 10, 2008 ]
       
   
 
Novice User

I have two children who were raised mostly vegan and free or processed foods and sugars, until I woke  up.  My son was the first.  He had chronic sinus infections for almost 1.5 years until I began giving him meat, cheese and sweets too.  We continued to eat organic unprocessed foods.  His mother has majority custody and has alientated me from the kids and continued feeding both my son and daughter the strict vegan diet.  Today both children suffer from anaphylactic attacks in which they suddenly loose the ability to breath.  It is a near death experience.  Only 8 years old my son has had a crown and 3 tooth extractions on account of infection and decay. The tooth with the crown actually broke as it was so weak.  The lies that people extoll about vegansim are worse then the lies we are told about where our meat comes.  I know the lies well, I used to ignore the feedback of my own body when attempting veganism and vegetarianism.  I have also seen the health problems of other vegan kids and the lies the parrents tell themselves and others.  I used to tell the same lies to myself and to others.  My son went to school with a boy with such health probelms and was going blind.  The mother remained firm on his veganism and the father was battling with her to allow him to eat meat.  Stop lying.  Beware before you spread such lies to others who might read your post and feed their children accordingly.  You have the right to Kill yourself with your diet but please spare your kids.  It is tantamount to child abuse.  Please give you children a little fish or chicken from time to time and try not to be dogmatic and extreme.  Your children will thank you for it later.

Raw an vegan diets are good for short term detox and health restoratation in adults. They are not meant for long term and are not healthy for young growing bodies.  

 [ Reply ]
  
  
Mountainmay
[ Joined on 07/07 ] [ Posted on July 4, 2008 ]
       
   
 
This user is BELOW novice level and all their comments need to be reviewed with great caution.

My friend is a vegan and raised her 2 kids vegan (they had the choice to eat meat if they wanted). They both EXCEL at school and extracurricular activities and are incredibly healthy (no deficiencies or disease) and very healthy looking compared to all the other obese and lethargic kids in the chicago suburbs. They are both in college on scholarships. I am a vegetarian (vegan hopeful) and my energy levels have vastly improved since eliminating meat and milk from my diet.  I will never go back.

This article is very inaccurate and to claim that eating meat will actually improve malnutrition in the world when it is the primary CAUSE of it is horrible.   Read THE CHINA STUDY. Amazing book.   www.thechinastudy.com/about.html

There is a lot of misinformation about veganism out there - even on this site! People are really wising up to the destructiveness that eating animal products has had to the earth and our health. It is just hard to change the way most of were raised, even though it isn't the healthiest way to live.

I am hopeful for all :)

 [ Reply ]

 
Truste
 
Mercola