SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
Salad Shocker: Do You Think All Salads Are Healthy?

Salad may seem an obvious meal choice when you’re watching your weight. But is it really? This AOL survey of some popular restaurant salads may make you think twice about what you order.

Some of the worst offenders include:

Dairy Queen’s Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
680 calories 48 grams fat
Chili’s Southwestern Cobb Salad
970 calories
Pizzeria Uno’s Chicken Waldorf Salad
920 calories 62 grams fat
Arby’s Santa Fe Salad
844 calories 55 grams fat

AOL Body



Dr. Mercola''s Comments Dr. Mercola's Comments:

Although fast food restaurants have made an effort to offer healthier fares over the past couple of years, prepackaged salads are still not your best option. With the additions of fried tortilla chips, fried chicken, and commercial dressings, you can easily end up with a less than ideal meal.  

This does NOT mean, however, that a salad is a worse option than a burger and fries, as they implied in this article. It’s mainly a matter of avoiding  the unhealthy toppings.

The absolute best thing you can do for yourself and your family is to take control of your meals by preparing them at home. If you want to get or stay healthy, learning to prepare your own food is one of the best prescriptions out there. Exchanging convenience for your health is a very lopsided "bargain."

Remember that if you want to start to Take Control of Your Health, someone in your family or someone that you employ is going to have to spend some time in the kitchen, freshly preparing unprocessed whole foods for you and your family.

If you're thinking that you truly don't have the time to do this, don't miss my past article, Six Easy Ways to Get Better Nutrition Even if You Don't Have the Time.

But, if you do order restaurant salads, keeping these few tips in mind can help you make your meal as healthy as possible:

  • Add chicken or egg. A salad is generally a healthy choice for lunch, especially if it’s loaded up with organic greens and fresh vegetables. However, you’ll likely find yourself hungry soon after if you don’t add any protein. (Just stay clear of the deep fried kind!)  It really saddens me that nearly all chicken choices for salad are only the breast or white meat.  For those of us that are protein types this is not at all satisfying as we would MUCH prefer the chicken thighs or legs, which have far more fat and more purine proteins

    The type of protein that’s best for you depends largely on your nutritional type. While carb types will do fine with some white-meat chicken or egg, protein types will want to opt for dark-meat chicken or even some red meat.

    If you choose to use egg, an even healthier option is to find a creative way to bring them along separately, and eat them raw in your salad.  This is much easier to implement at home. 
  • Ditch the commercial salad dressing. They’re typically full of trans fat, sugar, and other less-than-ideal ingredients. Don’t ruin a healthy salad with an over-processed dressing -- choose olive oil and vinegar instead.
  • Lose the bread. No matter what the meal, you’re better off without the bread. Also watch out for "hidden" bread in breading, toppings, and croutons.   

Going back to salads prepared at home for a moment, other benefits of doing this is that, not only can you make sure your produce is both fresh and organically grown, but you also have greater control over the type of vegetables included, as some vegetables are better for you than others, based on your nutritional type.

Little compares to the nutritional value of organic, raw, vegetables according to your biochemical composition. In addition to the B-vitamin folic acid, fresh vegetables have numerous other nutrients that will promote health and prevent diseases, especially neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson's. And, the many antioxidants and phytochemicals in vegetables will help keep your mind sharp.

If you are a strong protein type (like me), then you may find you don’t need as many vegetables. Perhaps as little as half a pound to a pound a day would be sufficient for the typical protein-type adult. Your vegetables would also be oriented more toward lower potassium varieties, like spinach, avocados, green beans, asparagus, mushrooms, celery, and cauliflower.

Regular lettuces and typically "wonderful" vegetables like collard greens, kale, and Swiss chard, are far too high in potassium for protein types and will tend to cause biochemical imbalances.

A carb type, on the other hand, may benefit from consuming far more vegetables, and the best varieties would include the collard greens, kale, Swiss chard, and so on, which were not ideal for protein types.

Please note that while I recommend organic vegetables for the most nutritional benefits, if you can’t find or afford them, don’t use this as an excuse to not eat any vegetables. Eating any vegetables, whether they are organic or not, is much better than not eating any vegetables at all.



Related Links:



Comment on This Article Community Comments (59)
 
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
All the more reason to eat at home. Take charge of what you and your family are eating by purchasing the vegetables yourself and preparing them at home with healthy olive oil & apple cider vinegar dressing that is so easy to make yourself.

What they don't tell you in the article is what type of chemicals you are ingesting by eating the burger & fries as compared to the salad.

 
Vicki Marie
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 6/2006
Vicki Marie  
Replied

Katee Roux
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 7/2007
Katee Roux  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
So right, Vicki Marie.  I was reading & thinking, how can they possibly compare these calories to fries?  Do potatoes, which are mostly starch anyway, cut into slices & fried, often in transfat, have ANY nutritional value?

Yes, those dressings are often horrible, full of HFCS & lots of chemicals.  But what is under the dressing usually has SOME nutritional content.  I'd prefer a (dry) salad over fries any day.  I find i don't need any dressing most of the time now.  I usually order a salad with some avocado & sometimes feta cheese, & don't miss the dressing at all.  

Question - how important is lettuce, nutritionally?  These days my homemade "salad" usually is cucumber, zuccini, tomatoes, avocado, maybe some carrot or beet, whole sweet peas, etc.  Am i missing much by not bothering with lettuce?

An aside, i think i mentioned that my secret shame was a Big Mac meal.  (I know, i'm awful.)  I did cheat about 3 weeks back & ordered it, & couldn't eat the fries.  Now that i've had the good, healthy stuff for so long, the fries were simply awful (where as i used to crave them).


Amanda Rose
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Amanda Rose  
 
Posted On Sep 27, 2007

Katee,

I like your vegetable salad idea. Lettuce does have some nutrients, greens of course have more. Here's how we select lettuce (because I still prefer some lettuce in my salad):

www.rebuild-from-depression.com/.../saladgreens101.html

Amanda


 
 
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
In addition to HFCS, also beware that many popular salad dressings are often full of high omega-6 oils, like soybean oil, that will throw off your omega-6 to omega-3 ratio.

 
Bryan - oz4caster
Apprentice User Apprentice User, Joined On 6/2006
Bryan - oz4caster  
Replied

Patty D
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2007
Patty D  
 
Posted On Sep 12, 2007
The only soy that isn't an "antinutrient" is FERMENTED ORGANIC NON-GMO like misa and tempeh.  Also, there is growing concern the phytoestrogens in soy is contributing to obesity, increased height and especially early puberty in girls because of the large amount of soy now consumed.  I'm sure there are some affects in boys too, I just haven't read of that yet.


samurai
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 4/2007
samurai  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Thanks so much for the info, Bryan!


samurai
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 4/2007
samurai  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Bryan,
I did not know that about soy bean oil. 
I don't understand, is edamame good or bad for you?


Bryan - oz4caster
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
Bryan - oz4caster  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
samurai ... read Dr Mary Enig's excellent article: The Skinny on Fats

As far as endame (soy beans), I believe the bad outweighs the good, as they are high in phytoestrogens, protease inhibitors, and leptins.  I stay away from soy.  There are plenty of better foods to enjoy : )


Bryan - oz4caster
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
Bryan - oz4caster  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Let me try that again ... soy has LECTINS not leptins ... and the edit button is gone : )


Amanda Rose
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Amanda Rose  
 
Posted On Sep 27, 2007

Here's a list of the Omega 6 to Omega 3 ratio of vegetable oils:

www.rebuild-from-depression.com/.../vegetable_oil_and_depression.html



chirocheer
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 8/2006
chirocheer  
 
Posted On Sep 27, 2007

for more info on soy (and how bad it is for you), check out www.westonaprice.org.  stay away from all soy products unless they are fermented!


 
 
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
One of the reasons why i stay away from these restaurants no pun intended... I know a few people in the industry that claims most restaurants almost never ever wash their salads and when they do they do a half ass job at it anyways - yuck.....

The only salad dressing we use is freshly made from  extra virgin olive oil ,balsamic vinegar, fresh crushed garlic, sea salt , black pepper, and oregano and kalamata olives and only takes a few mins to prepare. We sometimes sprinkle some feta cheese on our salad and the taste is "extraordinaire",  the kids just love it that's why dinner absolutely must include a healthy home made salad............We would'nt want it any other way really.......

 
seg
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 11/2006
seg  
Replied

emm76
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 7/2006
emm76  
 
Posted On Sep 27, 2007

I ordered the lettuce wraps from Chili's and there was dirt (yes DIRT) on  the lettuce.  I know they don't wash the lettuce.  Probably don't wash much of anything including thier hands!


 
 
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
I spend approx. 6 out of 7 days on the road, except when I take one of my vacations. The restraunts serve because many say this is what they want. Because of lack of information they do not know what to eat to be healthy, until they are in some physical ailment.

Well, even tho I carry a cooler with me and stock many of my own store bought items, I do eat out often. Often try to stay at places with a kitchnette.

For salads. I always leave the dressing or ask for extra virgin olive oil/vinegar on the side. Or give me a tab of cottage cheese on top. I eat half of the salad and take the rest out for the next meal.  I preferr to find salad buffets and then I can pick and choose my tastes and calorie intake. Of course this often leaves one paying alot for a little. Some buffets allow you to carry out. In that case I do and plan it for 2-3 meals with my choice of vegetables and greens.

Eating out leaves one to often leave half the meal or doggy it out the door. Of course when one eats small meals thru out the day and eats only one big meal a day. Well, eating out is not conclusive to a small meal and one needs to plan this for their bigger meal.

When one wants to eat healthy they can on the road.

 
charleydan
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 8/2007
charleydan  
Replied

Birdlady
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
Birdlady  
 
Posted On Sep 27, 2007

I just assume every single thing in a buffet (including the salads) is coated with preservatives.  Eating out where I live is next to impossible because there are only a handful of restaurants and they are rather scary. I see the people who come out of them and cringe.

Just because the lettuce is lettuce doesn't mean they don't spray it with preservatives so it keeps longer or wash it with tap water full of chlorine and fluoride.

Most of the lettuce you are getting at a buffet is bagged and God only knows where it came from!

Eating out is disastrous to eating healthy.


 
 
 
Posted On Sep 12, 2007
In addition to the restaurant salads mentioned in this article, and many HARMFUL salad dressing that are real chemical cocktails (Clorox owns Hidden Valley brand loaded with HFCS, and even Newman's brand is fake in many cases) avoid ALL bagged salads like the PLAGUE, full of inert flushed gases, salt, preservatives, stabilizers, anti browning agents, nitrites, nitrates, sulfites, sulfates, modified starches, refined sugars, fake colors and flavors, etc,, that are NOT declared in many cases, as 'aids to processing'.

 
Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
Replied

Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
 
Posted On Sep 12, 2007
Oh, yes, I forgot, if you do not believe my 'dressing' comments, just merely read the labels some day on these branded salad dressing offerings at the supermarket chains...

As usual, it comes down to COMMON SENSE, if it's processed, there is a higher probability it's NOT good for you.

Uncle Russ


Patty D
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2007
Patty D  
 
Posted On Sep 12, 2007
samurai, I got the diet from my Chiropractor.  It's from Maximized Living by Ben Lerner...(hope I can say that here).  I haven't found it spelled out online, not the particular one I'm on.  You go through a Maximized Living trained chiro, they teach classes and all kinds of stuff.  It's actually called The Advanced/Healing Diet. There's also a Basic Diet that does allow grains and other stuff.


Patty D
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2007
Patty D  
 
Posted On Sep 12, 2007
Before I started this sugar free/grain free diet, I read labels to ascertain calories, fat and salt.  Once I started really reading them, I was grossed out.  I now make my own mayonaise and my own salad dressings.  I know beyond doubt what goes into them...well I did til I recently read about supermarket olive oil.


Patty D
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2007
Patty D  
 
Posted On Sep 12, 2007
Nope samurai, none of the above.  I'm on something called THE HEALING DIET .  (I think it's similar to what Dr. Mercola recommends). When I started I was desperately sick and well over 100lbs overweight.  One of the purposes of the grain/sugar restriction is to retrain the body to burn fat by depriving it of sugar.  Even whole grains turn to sugar.  It has to do with LEPTIN and INSULIN RESISTANCE.   For the first time in my life, I'm losing weight, have more energy than I can ever remember and I'm no longer starving myself.  Obviously it's working.  It doesn't have to be a lifetime restriction.  Once you are well on your way to healing, lost much of the weight you need to etc you can slowly introduce some things back.  I still have a long way to go, so I'm not even considering adding anything in.  The first week or so is hard, after than cravings are gone.  I never thought I could give up breads, never was much of a sweets eater, but I don't even want it anymore.  Something I've done on my own, after lots of research is added a lot of lacto-fermented products to my diet:  milk kefir, water kefir, cultured veggies and kombucha tea so far.  For me it's been miraculous.


samurai
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 4/2007
samurai  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Patty,
You don't have any Tabouli, Quinoa or Oatmeal either?
Wow!  It's enough that I have given up Cokes and Grey Goose, I cannot imagine giving up even the good grains!    :)


samurai
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 4/2007
samurai  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Right on Patty.  Congrats on your accomplishment!!  I am going to query that book.  I bet it is similar to Dr. Perricone's weight loss diet.


PepperR23
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
PepperR23  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Russ, I found that my health improved once I stopped using the bagged or plastic boxed organic salad mixes and began preparing my own from local organic farm produce.  Also I have found that storing the lettuce in a covered glass bowl really improves the flavor of the salad.  I also keep my organic tomatoes in glass bowls on the counter top.  The improvement to their taste is amazing!


Vicki Marie
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Vicki Marie  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Patty D

Pat yourself on the back, you deserve it. You will be a living testimony to those that know you.

I've made all those same fermented drinks and foods except the kombucha tea which I have been wanting to try. I understand you need a starter from someone. Could you email me how you got started and any tips you have at VickiM66@aol.com . TXS!


Katee Roux
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 7/2007
Katee Roux  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
I'm doing something similar to Patty.  No grains at this time.  Like she said, it isn't for life, but to be healthy.  When i'm better, i'll be able to add in quinoa & oats, & some other healthy ones, but still a very small part of my diet.  I am doing about a tablespoon of flax seed daily.  I eat it as a snack, sometimes with a little powdered stevia & some cinnamon.

I have just started making my own yogurt.  (They say keeping it at a constant temp for about 8 hours is important.  Last week i put it in the car for the day - didn't drive the car of course.  I'd heated the milk to 100 degrees, & in the car it stayed at that temp all day long.  I've heard 110 is better, but this temp seemed ok).

I do allow myself some 100% dark chocolate.  I shave it & mix it with stevia, almond extract, melt it with coconut oil & a little flax oil, & blend it in raw milk.  It is wonderful!  Feels sinful, since i'm doing no sugar, not even fruits.  Better than anything Nestle Quick ever thought of!


Katee Roux
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 7/2007
Katee Roux  
 
Posted On Sep 13, 2007
Oh, & i can't match Patty's weight loss, but i've lost 15 pounds since i began this 5 weeks ago.  I'm not doing this for weight loss, but for health, but this is a delightful plus.

 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.